The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Hinkley not Necessary says ECIU

26 August 2016 | Updated 01 January 1970

The Government is due to make a decision on whether to approve the building of Hinkley Point C shortly but analysis by the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit (ECIU) has found that a mixture of established approaches including wind farms, cables connecting the UK grid with other countries and gas-fired power stations, together with measures to manage demand, would save the UK around £1 billion per year while keeping the lights on and meeting climate targets.

ECIU director Richard Black said the report shows that while Hinkley C could form part of the UK’s future energy mix, it is not essential: “Despite years of debate on Hinkley, we’re still not sure whether or not it’s going to get built – the Prime Minister is due to make a decision next month, but even if she says ‘yes’ there are many other issues that could derail the project, including legal cases and EDF’s financial woes.

“So we wanted to know how essential Hinkley is for the ‘energy trilemma’ – keeping the lights on whilst cutting greenhouse gas emissions and keeping costs down."

“Our conclusion is that it’s not essential - using tried and tested technologies, with nothing unproven or futuristic, Britain can meet all its targets and do so at lower cost," Black continued. "So if Mrs May decides to go ahead with Hinkley, all well and good – if she decides not to or if the project stumbles at a later stage, we have alternatives.”


The report found:

  • The UK could bring as much electricity into the grid as Hinkley would generate by building as few as four big wind farms (additional to those the UK and partners will build anyway) or building three additional interconnector cables.

  • The UK could negate the need for at least two-fifths of Hinkley’s electricity by cutting waste – using electricity more efficiently and productively.

  • Hinkley’s 3.2GW of peak demand could be replaced through demand-side response (additional to improvements to be made make anyway), additional interconnectors or additional gas-fired units generating at peak times – or a mixture of all.


All of these alternatives on their own work out cheaper than Hinkley the ECIU report claims:

Replacing all Hinkley electricity with additional offshore wind farms would cut the average household bill by £10-20 per year. Replacing all Hinkley’s peak-time output with gas-fired units would save £16bn in infrastructure costs.

ECIU Energy Analyst Dr Jonathan Marshall said the changing nature of electricity systems places a question mark over Hinkley’s relevance: “The UK’s energy infrastructure is ageing and increasingly unreliable, so clearly we need to replace bits of it and there’s no doubt that nuclear reactors generally supply low-carbon electricity reliably. But electricity systems are changing rapidly across the world. I think our report illustrates the reason why things are changing – increasingly, smart, flexible and renewable equals cheap and reliable.”

The full report, Hinkley: What If? Can the UK solve its energy trilemma without Hinkley Point C?, is available by Clicking Here

Article written by Robin Snow | Published 26 August 2016


Related Articles

Legal Challenge to Hinkley Point

Greenpeace and Ecotricity have released a legal opinion by three ‘eminent’ lawyers on the French government’s proposed package of financial support for...

 Read Full Article
Six Ways Facilities Managers Can Plan For A More Sustainable Future

In honour of Earth Day, here are six simple ways facilities managers can plan for a more sustainable future.  It’s a common misconception that making...

 Read Full Article
Charities Benefit From Green Rewards

Green Rewards works with a number of corporate, local authority and university clients to provide bespoke services to engage and reward people for following sustainable...

 Read Full Article
Plugging In To The Charging Market

FM provider ABM?UK has reached an agreement with ChargePoint, the electric vehicle (EV) charging network. ABM now has the rights to distribute, install and maintain...

 Read Full Article
Two Green Apples A Day

Acorn Engineering Group and AIS BMS were both presented with Green Apple awards on Monday November 6 at a ceremony hosted in the Houses of Parliament. The presentation...

 Read Full Article
Powering Past Coal - Getting Rid Of Dirtiest Fuel

A global alliance has been launched by the UK and Canada to lead the rest of the world in committing to an end to the use of unabated coal power. At COP23 on Nov 16, more...

 Read Full Article
Blooming Marvellous - Bloomberg HQ Is Worlds Most Sustainable

Bloomberg’s new European headquarters building, which just opened in London, has been rated as the World’s Most Sustainable Office Building. The building...

 Read Full Article
Greenhouse Gas Concentrations Surge To New Record

Concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere surged at a record-breaking speed in 2016 to the highest level in 800 000 years, according to the World Meteorological...

 Read Full Article
BT Rings Out Early Emissions Targets

BT has set new 2030 carbon emissions target after achieving its previous goal four years early. BT's target of an 80% reduction of its carbon emissions was due to be...

 Read Full Article
Worlds First Floating Windfarm Sets Sail

International energy company Statoil has applied new thinking and new engineering to its latest project just off the Scottish coast. The company is building Hywind - the...

 Read Full Article