The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Manual Compliance Management Can’t Keep Up With Complex Contractor Networks

Manual Compliance Management Can’t Keep Up With Complex Contractor Networks
16 November 2026
 

Dale Jones, Technical Director at SafeContractor, looks at a concerning gap between contractor compliance policies and day-to-day practice, highlighted in new research from SafeContractor’s The State of Contractor Assurance 2026 Report.

Facilities managers have always had to balance keeping buildings safe and operational with managing costs, meeting occupant expectations and acting quickly when things go wrong. But increasing reliance on external suppliers adds pressure to ensure every contractor who arrives on site is competent, insured, appropriately trained and working to the required standards.



This is becoming harder to achieve through spreadsheets, multiple email chains, fragmented records and disconnected processes.

New research from SafeContractor’s The State of Contractor Assurance 2026 Report highlights a concerning gap between contractor compliance policies and day-to-day practice. Just 14% of organisations say they fully verify every contractor they engage, while almost a quarter (23%) of contractors surveyed said they had started work before compliance checks were complete.

For facilities teams, this creates significant operational, legal, safety, financial and reputational issues. If documentation is incomplete, expired or buried in an inbox, organisations can quickly lose sight of who is undertaking work, whether they are qualified for the task at hand and whether the right controls are in place before the work begins.


Limitations Of Manual Processes

Manual systems may seem manageable at first, but contractor arrangements never stay simple. Even single sites involve multiple contractors – from maintenance and repair providers and cleaners to security, fire-safety specialists and emergency call-out suppliers. For a multi-site estate, the contractor network is substantially more complex.

Each contractor may need different levels of insurance coverage, health and safety policies, risk assessments, training records, accreditations, licences, method statements and proof of competence. Crucially, any evidence gathered should not be seen as a one-off onboarding exercise that is checked once and forgotten. Certificates expire, insurance policies renew, teams change and the nature of a contractor’s work can shift over time.

Excel spreadsheets and email folders should never be relied on to provide an accurate, up-to-date and reliable compliance system. A document may have been received, but has it been reviewed? Is it current? Has it been signed? Does it apply to the specific work being carried out? Any uncertainty results in teams having to chase information and resolve any compliance gaps rather than managing risk proactively.


Lack Of Visibility

Visibility is a key challenge, with our research suggesting that it often weakens further down the supply chain. Just 43% of hiring clients say they have full visibility of subcontractors working under main contractors, while 56% say subcontractors are appointed without direct client involvement often or very often. That leaves a sizeable risk of organisations losing sight of who is carrying out work on their behalf.

Without a consistent assurance process, accountability can also become blurred. Some organisations say responsibility for contractor compliance is the health and safety team’s job (23%), some say project delivery (22%), others think it’s procurement (20%), while 16% place responsibility with the main contractor. Over one in five (21%) believe responsibility is shared by everyone. With no single team or role directly responsible, it’s easy for things to get overlooked.

This is particularly important where contractors work in high-risk environments or carry out activities that impact residents, employees, visitors and the public. In social housing, for example, contractors may enter people’s homes and carry out safety-critical repairs. In manufacturing, they may work around complex machinery or operational processes. In facilities management, they may be responsible for maintaining essential systems that affect the safety and usability of a building.

The consequences can be significant. Nearly half of hiring clients identify project delays as a potential result of compliance gaps, while 42% cite safety incidents and 40% cite reputational damage. Our report also found that 34% of hiring clients that have experienced compliance-related issues point to a lack of subcontractor visibility as a contributing factor.


The Need For Continuous Assurance

Pre-qualification remains an essential first step, but it is not the end of the process. Contractor assurance needs to continue throughout a project. Once work is underway, regular reviews are vital, alongside clear records of who is on site, including subcontractors brought in after work has started.

Monitoring tails off over time as projects progress, particularly once relationships are established and contractors are seen as “known” to the client.

While 82% of hiring clients say they reassess contractors regularly or periodically during projects, only 70% of contractors say clients recheck or monitor compliance at this stage. The gap remains after work is complete, when 69% of hiring clients say reassessment continues, compared with 61% of contractors.

Familiarity can create a false sense of security. Even where a contractor has a long-standing relationship with an organisation, personnel, subcontracting arrangements, insurance, qualifications and site conditions can change. Regular reassessment helps ensure compliance controls remain suitable for the work being carried out, rather than relying on previous experience or older documentation.

Structured contractor assurance systems help facilities teams centralise contractor information, set consistent requirements and flag when evidence needs to be reviewed or renewed. This can reduce administrative effort while improving risk management.

Continuous assurance can also clarify responsibility. Effective assurance depends on everyone working from the same, current information. This gives decision-makers greater confidence that contractors have completed the right checks before beginning work and that requirements remain in place as work progresses.

Contractor networks are growing, work is often delivered at pace, and supply chains can extend far beyond the first-tier provider. A system that offers a single view of contractor compliance and competence can provide the consistency needed to manage those pressures.

Ultimately, manual processes struggle because they rely on people manually joining up information across too many documents, inboxes and teams. As contractor networks become more complex, assurance must become more continuous, coordinated and visible. The goal is to ensure that compliance information supports better decisions in practice – helping organisations protect people, keep operations running and demonstrate that their contractor controls are more than a policy on paper.


1. The State of Contractor Assurance 2026 Report by SafeContractor – see here.


Picture: A headshot of Dale Jones, Technical Director at SafeContractor.

Article written by Dale Jones | Published 16 November 2026

Share



Related Articles

Documentation Does Not Demonstrate Competence

Dale Jones, Technical Director at SafeContractor, shares how documentation does not equal competence when considering supply chain contractor compliance. For those...

 Read Full Article
Hotels And Hospitality Venues Present Unique Maintenance Challenges

SFG20 reveals the maintenance challenges facing the hospitality sector and how FM teams can improve compliance and efficiency. From budget hotel chains to luxury...

 Read Full Article
Half Of FM Teams Are Not Confident In Achieving Compliance

Data from the latest SFG20 survey reveals the FM industry's biggest challenges, from compliance and budget constraints to technology and AI adoption. According to...

 Read Full Article
BESA Suspends 14 Members for Compliance Failures

The Building Engineering Services Association has suspended 14 member companies for failing to comply with audits. The 14 companies failed to meet the Building...

 Read Full Article
BSIF Launches New PPE Safety Checklist

The British Safety Industry Federation has published a checklist to help users check whether personal protective equipment is up to standard. Recent research from the...

 Read Full Article
CHAS Acquired by Veriforce

CHAS 2013 Ltd, the provider of compliance and risk management solutions, is to be acquired by supply chain risk company Veriforce for an undisclosed fee. Established...

 Read Full Article
EVO Partners With Not-For-Profit Housing Company to Tackle Homelessness in London

Not-for-profit company Capital Letters has partnered with property maintenance business EVO Digital Technologies to digitalise its repairs, maintenance and compliance...

 Read Full Article
Digital ID and Recruitment – What Do FMs Need to Know?

Whether recruiting remotely or in-person, facilities management businesses must keep up to date with the latest digital ID changes to remain compliant. Stefan...

 Read Full Article
Compliance Fines after Electrician’s Injuries at B&M Warehouse

B&M and Daker have been fined after an electrician suffered serious burns to 15 per cent of his body when he was caught in an explosion at a warehouse in...

 Read Full Article
Business Energy Reporting –  Are you Combining ESOS and SECR?

When it comes to energy and emissions reporting, there are ways to streamline both the work and cost involved in being compliant. TEAM Energy, who helps organisations...

 Read Full Article