The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

QC Appointed to Head Up RICS Suppression Scandal Review

QC Appointed to Head Up RICS Suppression Scandal Review
09 February 2021

Peter Oldham QC has been appointed to conduct the independent review into the events that led to the firing of four non-executive RICS directors in 2019.

Oldham is a specialist in advising and litigating in public, local government, education, employment, procurement and state aid law.

It is hoped by RICS that the review will be completed by early April 2021, and that the findings and recommendations will be published “as soon as possible thereafter”.

The Steering Committee which drafted the terms of reference and selected Peter Oldham QC to lead the independent review was made up of members of RICS Governing Council: Nick Maclean, Marion Ellis, Uche Obi, Martin Eberhardt and Rob Wilson.

RICS confirmed on 21 January 2021 that the independent review would go ahead, after four non-executive directors claimed that they were let go from their positions after drawing attention to a potentially damaging BDO governance report. 


UK’s Former Chief Construction Adviser Says RICS is “Too Diverse”


Paul Morrell, former Chief Construction Adviser to the government between 2009-2012, has accused RICS of being “too diverse” and “losing sight of the interests of people closer to home.”

Morrell told that RICS’ leadership had acted in an “arrogant and naive” way over the BDO financial report.

He told them: “It’s naive because the scandal would never have arisen, notwithstanding the frustrations with the institution, if they had been sensible about responding to their non-execs.

“How you’d imagine that people [the current leadership] who are well respected and well connected would allow that to happen without engaging the interests of the press, I think is just naive or is arrogance that overcomes naivete.

“The other arrogance is to imagine that a professional institution is not really a members organisation at all and must not be held back by the mass of its membership.

“This is effectively saying that the institution’s leadership has a better idea of what’s good for the members than they do and I think this has led to them replacing the interests of individual members with a mad international chase for numbers, congratulating themselves upon that, and losing sight of the interests of people closer to home.”


Article written by Ella Tansley | Published 09 February 2021


Related Tags

Related Articles

Chair Appointed to Run RICS Suppression Scandal Review Resigns

A QC appointed to conduct the review into the events that led to the firing of four non-executive RICS directors in 2019 has resigned. Peter Oldham QC, a specialist in...

 Read Full Article
Former RICS Directors say Group Rejected Their Request to Go Public

RICS’ claim that four sacked non-executive directors asked for their departure to be kept secret, has been debunked by the NEDs themselves. As reported on...

 Read Full Article
RICS to Hold Independent Review Into Alleged Suppression Scandal  

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors is to proceed with an independent review into the events that led to the firing of four directors, who allegedly raised...

 Read Full Article
Facilities Management Will Take Centre Stage Post-Pandemic, Says RICS And BDO 

FMs will be “the first responders” in inspiring the confidence to return back to work safely, says a report from BDO’s Management and Acquisitions...

 Read Full Article
SFG20 Launches Online Tool to Help FMs Estimate Maintenance Costs

A digital tool to help facilities managers accurately price the specific maintenance requirements of any building has been launched by SFG20. The SFG20 Resource...

 Read Full Article
Martin Samworth Named as New Chair of RICS Board

RICS has announced that its new Board Chair will be Martin Samworth FRICS. The establishment of this new RICS Board is one of the key recommendations from June...

 Read Full Article
RICS Takes Steps to Improve Diversity in the Built Environment

Alongside other sector organisations, RICS is making plans to “drive forward the creation of a more diverse, equitable and inclusive sector”. In a...

 Read Full Article
BESA, RICS and NBS Unite to Align on Building Data Standards

In what has been described as “a momentous game-changing moment”, RICS, BESA and NBS have created a roundtable collaboration forum, to align the data...

 Read Full Article
Lord Bichard Joins RICS as Interim Senior Independent Governor

As part of the implementation of his review recommendations, RICS has appointed Lord Michael Bichard as Interim Senior Independent Governor. Lord Bichard, who will...

 Read Full Article
Lord Bichard’s RICS Review Results Published

Lord Bichard, in his independent review of RICS, recommends “nothing less than a transformation of the Institution carried out at pace.” He found that the...

 Read Full Article