The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Suppliers Used As Bank Of Carillion

Frank Field MP
16 May 2018

Carillion used its suppliers to 'prop up its failing business model'  the Work and Pensions and BEIS (Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy) Committees said on May 14 as it published evidence from Santander, the bank which operated Carillion’s Early Payment Facility.

The evidence cam in the form of a letter dated February 2018 from Patricia Halliday, Chief Risk Officer at Santander, regarding Carillion's Early Payment Facility programme. The Committees identified Carillion as a 'notorious late payers'.

Despite being signatories of the Prompt Payment Code, Carillion were 'notorious late payers' who forced standard payment terms of 120 days on its suppliers. The EPF - also known as 'reverse factoring' and 'supply chain financing' - allowed suppliers to be paid earlier: at the price of taking a discounted payment.

Two major credit ratings agencies, Moody's and Standard & Poor's, have claimed that Carillion's accounting for their EPF concealed its true level of borrowing from financial creditors. They argue the EPF structure meant Carillion had a financial liability to the banks that should have been presented in the annual account as 'borrowing'. Instead Carillion choose to present these as liabilities to 'other creditors'. Moody's claim that as much as £498 million was misclassified as a result.


Factor in liquidation

Carillion's financial statements did not highlight the EPF but some analysts spotted it. Carillion's board minutes in April 2015 refer to 'disappointing' analysis by UBS that had factored both the pension deficit and the EPF in Carillion's total debt position. The May 2015 minutes state that shorting of Carillion’s shares was up significantly and that the 'bulk had followed the UBS note in March'.  Santander finally withdrew the discounted early payment facility in December 2017. Although it was just weeks before the company was forced to apply for liquidation,


Excuses, excuses

According to the committees' report, Santander’s decision to terminate this facility has featured on the long and varied list of factors Carillion’s directors have attempted to blame for its demise. In the Santander letter, the bank describes the series of events which 'undermined Santander’s confidence in Carillion’s financial position', including 'lack of progress with the restructuring plan' that Santander had provided new bridging finance for,and the expected 'detailed business and restructuring plans' being further delayed. The bank’s 'outstanding exposure to Carillion in relation to the invoices purchased from suppliers under the programme is £91 million' - this amount is 'separate from Santander’s committed exposures to Carillion for which we have taken significant additional bad debt provisions'.


Chairs' comments

Rt Hon Frank Field MP, Chair of the Work and Pensions Committee, said:  "Carillion displayed utter contempt for its suppliers, many of them the small businesses that are the lifeblood of the UK’s economy. The company used its suppliers as a line of credit to shore up its fragile balance sheet, then in another of its accounting tricks ‘reclassified’ this borrowing to hide the true extent of its massive debt.

"This knocks down for good the stance of the Carillion board that whingeing and blaming others can be any defence."

Rachel Reeves MP, Chair of the BEIS Committee, said:  "The collapse of Carillion left small businesses and sub-contractors out-of-pocket with many left unpaid for months and facing ruin. It’s a bitter irony that while Carillion were fully signed up to the Government’s Prompt Payment Code, they were making their suppliers hang on for 120 days or more to be paid. Carillion’s early payment facility ripped off their suppliers, forcing them to accept a cut in what they were owed, and was a blatant attempt by Carillion management to prop up their failing business model."

Picture: Frank Field MP.

Article written by Brian Shillibeer | Published 16 May 2018


Related Articles

Accounts Committee Slam Government On Contracting & Procurement

A failure to ensure contractors could do what they were bidding for at the price they were bidding, its relationship with Carillion and an abject failure to encourage...

 Read Full Article
Government Contracts - Playing Field Levelled For SMEs

On April 10, the government announced tough new measures to level the playing field for smaller businesses bidding to win government contracts - a part response to the...

 Read Full Article
Lawyers Open 12 Billion Of Government Work To SMEs

On 8th January, even before the Carillion fiasco unravelled, thousands of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) were made able to bid for up to £12 billion...

 Read Full Article
Trial of Carillion Chair and CEO Cancelled 

A trial involving the former Carillion Chair and interim CEO has been cancelled by the Insolvency Service, as proceedings are “no longer in the public...

 Read Full Article
KPMG Fined £21 Million for Carillion Audit Failings 

Big Four accounting firm KPMG has been fined for “exceptional” breaches when auditing the now-liquidated FM company Carillion. The initial £30...

 Read Full Article
Ex-Carillion CEO Disqualified as a Director for 8 Years

Richard Howson, former CEO of the now-defunct FM company Carillion, has been banned from holding directorship roles for eight years. The charge relates to...

 Read Full Article
Spotlight Interview – Francis West | Security Everywhere

Francis West is CEO of Security Everywhere, a company which helps SMEs to secure their money, data and reputation with managed security services. Francis is a trusted...

 Read Full Article
Government Introduces Energy Bills Discount Scheme for Businesses

A new package to help UK businesses manage rising energy costs is set to replace the current Energy Bill Relief Scheme. The Treasury's new Energy Bills Discount...

 Read Full Article
UK Government Introduces Day-One Right to Request Flexible Working

Millions of employees across the country are set to benefit from new legislation that means flexible working can be requested from the first day of employment. The...

 Read Full Article
UK SMEs are Unaware of UN Sustainability Goals

New YouGov research commissioned by business improvement and standards company, BSI has revealed the lack of awareness of the UN Sustainable Development Goals by UK...

 Read Full Article