The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

KPMG Fined Over Carillion Audits

KPMG Fined Over Carillion Audits
26 July 2022

The Financial Reporting Council has fined KPMG £14.4 million for providing misleading information during an audit of former construction and facilities management company Carillion.

Former KPMG auditors Peter Meehan, Alistair Wright, Richard Kitchen, and Adam Bennett were also handed fines that vary from £30,000 to £250,000, and banned from being members of The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) for varying lengths of time.

Pratik Paw, who had not yet qualified as an accountant at the time of the misconduct, was severely reprimanded and was “not found to have acted dishonestly” in his role.

KPMG admitted its liability for the acts of all the individuals involved. They also agreed to pay £3.95 million towards the Executive Counsel’s costs of the investigation together with the costs of the tribunal.

Elizabeth Barrett, Executive Counsel said: “Misconduct that deliberately undermines The Financial Reporting Council (FRC)’s ability to monitor and inspect the effectiveness of audits is extremely serious because it obstructs the FRC’s ability to protect the public interest. This case underlines the need for all professional accountants, regardless of seniority, to be aware of their individual responsibility to act honestly and with integrity in all areas of their work.”

You can read more about the context of the tribunal here.


What Were the Findings of Misconduct in the Carillon Audit?


The tribunal relates specifically to the audit of the financial statements of Carillion for the period ended 31 December 2016. The initial complaint concerned the provision of false and misleading documents and information to the AQR teams.

The tribunal found the following:


  • False and misleading meeting minutes had been created during the Carillion AQR inspection
  • An audit working paper on the selection of construction contracts for audit testing (the CCS Paper) was presented to AQR inspectors as if it had been created during the Carillion audit
  • Richard Kitchen made false representations in the CCS Paper that certain audit work had been performed during the Carillion audit


Picture: a photograph of a smartphone, showing Carillion's logo. Image Credit: Shutterstock. 

Article written by Ella Tansley | Published 26 July 2022


Related Articles

KPMG Boss Apologises for Misconduct on Carillion Audits

Jonathan Holt has apologised for KPMG misleading the Financial Reporting Council during an investigation into the firm’s 2016 audit of the now-defunct FM company,...

 Read Full Article
KPMG Fined £21 Million for Carillion Audit Failings 

Big Four accounting firm KPMG has been fined for “exceptional” breaches when auditing the now-liquidated FM company Carillion. The initial £30...

 Read Full Article
KPMG and Carillion – What’s the Latest?

In addition to the FRC tribunal regarding the 2016 Carillion audit, KPMG is now being sued by the government for £1.3 billion. According to released court...

 Read Full Article
Interserve's £90m A Year Auditors Under FRC Investigation

The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has commenced an investigation into the audit by Grant Thornton of the financial statements of Interserve Plc for the years ended 31...

 Read Full Article
Trial of Carillion Chair and CEO Cancelled 

A trial involving the former Carillion Chair and interim CEO has been cancelled by the Insolvency Service, as proceedings are “no longer in the public...

 Read Full Article
Ex-Carillion CEO Disqualified as a Director for 8 Years

Richard Howson, former CEO of the now-defunct FM company Carillion, has been banned from holding directorship roles for eight years. The charge relates to...

 Read Full Article
Tribunal Rules Carillion Compensation Case Can Proceed 

Workers seeking compensation following Carillion's collapse have secured a significant legal victory. 263 Unite members are seeking compensation for when...

 Read Full Article
Construction has a Culture of Financial Deviance, Says LSBU

The collapse of corporate giant Carillion in January 2018 highlights a culture of financial deviance embedded at the heart of the UK construction sector, according...

 Read Full Article
NAO Criticises Prison Maintenance Transformation Plan

The government is failing to provide and maintain safe, secure and decent prisons - and some of the blame falls at the decision to outsource to Carillion and...

 Read Full Article
Kier Komes Krashing Down

The Kier Group's shares have been plummeting in a style reminiscent of Carillion and Interserve - and on Monday June 17 things got worse as the construction and FM...

 Read Full Article