The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Tuesday, 26 May

Going Ga Ga for Gagging

Local authorities have been using so-called ‘gagging orders’ to silence departing staff at a worrying rate according to a BBC report.

The BBC report on Radio 5 came from a Freedom of Information (FoI) and asked all the 433 district, city, county and regional councils in the UK about the use of gagging orders – or as they are officially termed – settlement deals.

There was a 70% response, revealing that 17,571 workers had signed a settlement agreement between 2010 and 2015, totalling £226.7 million. The BBC programme admitted that it was difficult to know how much the confidentiality part (or ‘enhanced payment’) of any agreement would have cost as the ending of employment would have included normal payments.

The City of Cardiff Council issued the most, totalling 2,008 and resulting in pay-outs totalling £5.5 million.

It was top of the list and it appeared that the course of action was regarded as routine, although it told the BBC that the policy had ended in January 2015. It argued that making enhanced payments would encourage more people to volunteer for redundancy and that bring savings.

This was a time of massive cutbacks in local government as impositions were made from Downing Street that forced many authorities to search for staff to leave by inducement. Wirral Council got 1,000 staff to take voluntary redundancy or early retirement between 2010 and 2012 with many others doing similar.


Gagging = silence

Where alarm bells started ringing in a way similar to what has been reported many times with NHS Trusts, was when whistleblowers were voicing concerns about the impact of cuts on the performance of the duties they were still expected to perform, often of a statutory nature.

The practice was enough to bring about condemnation from the Public Accounts Committee which saw it as a means of silencing critics or whistleblowers over matters that could have been embarrassing to local authorities. In 2014 the Chair told the BBC of her concerns. "There can be no excuse for silencing people who've got a legitimate concern," said Meg Hillier. "If an employee is being told they can't talk about something and bought off, that's not an acceptable use of these settlement agreements."

Worries about this have also been expressed by the Department for Communities and Local Government and a spokesperson stated that confidentiality clauses should not be used to "stop, stifle or control individuals from speaking out about concerns about their employer. There is no excuse for outrageous payoffs at a time when all parts of the public sector should be finding ways to save taxpayers.”

The aspect that has particularly concerned many has been the deliberate use by local authorities to silence those who believe potential wrongdoing or actions are occurring needing publicity.

The most obvious recent case was the so-called Trojan Horse case in Birmingham where some headteachers were encouraged to sign settlement agreements that would have stopped them talking about how a number of schools were introducing strict Islamic ‘principles’ in 2013. “The inquiry exposed that Birmingham [Council] let me and my colleagues down,” one headteacher anonymously told the BBC. “All I can conclude from that is that I actually became the problem because I was complaining too often and they could deal with me rather than actually dealing with the whole issue and exercising their duty of care to me.”

Picture: A BBC Radio 5 programme has exposed how local authorities have used ‘settlements’ to induce staff to leave – some involving gagging clauses although Cardiff City Council (pictured) insist they have stopped since January 2015

Article written by Mike Gannon


Related Articles

Renegotiating A Leasehold During COVID-19

Virtually all UK businesses rent their HQ and operational premises under commercial leases. As the impact of COVID-19 becomes clearer, the question about reducing tenant...

 Read Full Article
COVID-19 – Casting A Spotlight On Facilities Management Outsourcing 

Tim Wright, partner at international law firm Fladgate, shares his thoughts on the ongoing challenges around facilities management outsourcing amid the COVID-19 pandemic....

 Read Full Article
Free (And Compensated) To Do What They Want Any Old Time

Extinction Rebellion have won the legal challenge to a ban on their protests - meaning the organisation can again bring disruption to streets and offices with virtual...

 Read Full Article
WeWork Back To Work After Bank Rescue Package

WeWork the flexible/co-working office space company (which has expanded at a global rate) was rumoured to have been in severe financial dire straits with 2,000...

 Read Full Article
Hotel All At Sea Over Asbestos

Two companies have been fined. RJW Building Solutions, a contractor carrying out refurbishment work at the Sea Hotel in South Shields and Hotel 52, the client, were...

 Read Full Article
Security Boss Guilty Of 22 Counts Of Fraud

​A security boss has been found guilty of defrauding security operatives deployed at Heathrow and Tesco. Meanwhile the SIA has carried out a licence check blitz and two...

 Read Full Article
Unpaid Claims - Insurers Always Win

New research has revealed that companies who take their insurers to court or public arbitration over non-payment of a claim only win in around one in three cases. The...

 Read Full Article
Facial Recognition Now Available - But Trouble Brewing Ahead

A commercially available facial recognition system has just been launched. Meanwhile, developer Argent could be in hot water for using LFR and both the ICO and a...

 Read Full Article
Wrong Formula - Chemical Firms May Not Mix

The merger of two cleaning chemical firms has raised competition concerns. The CMA has provisionally found that Ecolab’s merger with Holchem may mean...

 Read Full Article
City Coke-ies Go To Chokey & Distraction Thieves Nabbed As Well

Distraction thieves operating in the City of London have been jailed and offences halved while an organised crime gang responsible for supplying cocaine to City workers...

 Read Full Article