The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Thursday, 2 April

NAO Official - Public Inquiries Are Expensive and Don't Achieve Goals

Grenfell

With a number of inquiries still in progress - not least in to Grenfell - it has emerged that spending, sharing and generally getting a positive outcome is out of control.

The government has spent more than £200 million on inquiries completed since 2005, yet it is not always clear to taxpayers what action government has taken in response to recommendations and whether inquiries have had the intended impact, according to an investigation carried out by the National Audit Office (NAO). The focus of the NAO’s investigation was on completed inquiries, not those that have yet to conclude.

The government can decide to hold an inquiry in response to public concerns about a particular event. Inquiries often investigate complex issues and their nature, size and subject matter can vary significantly. However, all inquiries face the challenge of maintaining public confidence and accomplishing what they set out to achieve within an acceptable timescale and cost.

 

£239 million on the 26 inquiries

The NAO found that the government has spent at least £239 million on the 26 inquiries which have concluded since 2005 and that the average duration of these inquiries was 40 months. Departments were not able to provide the NAO with evidence that they had consistently monitored and scrutinised the cost and progress of the inquiries they have sponsored.

 

Out of control

No single department is responsible for running inquiries across government and there are no formal criteria to determine the type of inquiry. Since 2014, the Cabinet Office and the Ministry of Justice have committed to various actions to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of inquiries originating from two parliamentary select committee reports. None of these commitments have been fulfilled. For example, they have not acted on recommendations to share best practice from inquiries or update and publish guidance for inquiry chairs and sponsor departments.

 

No oversight

There is no overall oversight across government for monitoring and tracking whether inquiries have achieved their intended impact and whether recommendations, where made, have been implemented. Departments vary in how transparent they are about actions taken in response to recommendations. For example, of the eight inquiries examined by the NAO that made recommendations, readily accessible information on progress was only available for half of these.

 

Costs

The scale of these inquiries is much larger than other forms of inquiry, such as select committee inquiries. The costs for the ten inquiries examined by the NAO ranged from £0.2 million to £24.9 million, and the nature of expenditure varied significantly. Overall, legal staff costs were the largest item of expenditure (an average of 36% of an inquiry’s cost, although this varied from less than 1% for the Morecambe Bay Investigation to 67% for the Mid Staffordshire Inquiry). The ten inquiries also varied in length, from 16 months (the Harris Review and Leveson Inquiry) to 84 months (for the Iraq Inquiry). For those inquiries for which information was available, teams spent an average of 102 days hearing testimony from 200 witnesses and considered more than 52,000 documents.

 

Ongoing

This investigation does not look at inquiries that have been established but have yet to conclude, such as the Grenfell Tower Inquiry and the Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse. The NAO have identified 11 government led inquiries which are currently ongoing.

Picture: Spending, sharing and generally getting a positive outcome from public inquiries is out of control - so what chance of justice for the victims of Grenfell and what chance of proper and long lasting change?

Article written by Brian Shillibeer

Share



Related Articles

New Fire Safety Bill Planned

The Home Office has introduced a new bill to improve fire safety in buildings in England and Wales. The intention of the bill is to, according to the official...

 Read Full Article
The Bourne Ultimatum

Enhancing a fire door or curtain with a transparent vision panel should be considered in an attempt to assist both fire wardens and fire fighters says Stuart Bourne, a...

 Read Full Article
NAO Criticises Prison Maintenance Transformation Plan

The government is failing to provide and maintain safe, secure and decent prisons - and some of the blame falls at the decision to outsource to Carillion and...

 Read Full Article
FD60 - Crucial In Fire Door Safety

Yale Door and Window Solutions has successfully tested a number of its products to meet the FD60 fire door specification as part of a commitment to improving fire safety...

 Read Full Article
Brentford Hotel Fire - Was Cladding Involved?

A fire at a Travelodge hotel on December 4 prompted ThisWeekinFM to ask was any type of cladding (particularly aluminium panels containing a plastic filling) ...

 Read Full Article
Building In Safety - What's Next In Fire Reform

Building a Safer Future: Proposals for Reform of the Building Safety Regulatory System is the title of a paper and consultation that closed in July that will inform...

 Read Full Article
The Facilities Event And Sister Exhibitions At Birmingham NEC

The Facilities Event and sister exhibitions at Birmingham NEC saw good steady footfall with a mix of subject matter in seminar sessions while exhibitors worked well....

 Read Full Article
Grenfell - Possible Prosecutions Delayed Until 2021

If anyone or any organisation is to face prosecution for the Grenfell disaster, it is unlikely that the Crown Prosecution Service will be in a position even to consider...

 Read Full Article
Parliamentary Estate Contract Let As Committee Still Dally Over Restoration

Imtech Inviron have retained and significantly extended their technical facilities maintenance contract at the Houses of Parliament while the Joint Committee on the Draft...

 Read Full Article
Government Offers Combustible Cladding Ban And Fire Door Inspection Advice

Having issued a ban on combustible materials on new high-rise homes, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has established the Building Safety...

 Read Full Article