The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

What's The Difference Between Net-Zero Carbon and Carbon Neutral?

What's The Difference Between Net-Zero Carbon and Carbon Neutral?
16 August 2021 | Updated 17 August 2021
 

Net-zero carbon and carbon neutral are terms that are often used interchangeably, but how do they differ?

Dr Torill Bigg, a Chartered Engineer with over 20 years of experience specialising in innovative solutions to environmental protection, explains the differences between these two terms.

Bigg holds a PhD from Cranfield University's School of Industrial and Manufacturing Science, is the author of seven published peer-reviewed papers and is a Member of the Institute of Chemical Engineers. She spearheads Tunley Engineering’s work in reducing the carbon emissions of businesses across the globe utilising her academic and professional experience in finding grounded and cost-effective solutions to the climate crisis.

 

"There are carbon offset schemes offered that are sold on an arbitrary average carbon footprint basis, as opposed to a quantified footprint. The risk with these is that they offer the temptation of an easy-to-buy option, which not only does not include any emission reductions they also may fail to meet sufficient offset to address the problem of climate change. These are sold on the basis that a true quantification of your carbon footprint can be expensive, time-consuming and complicated but this need not be the case."

 

Net-Zero Or Carbon Neutral?

 

As understanding of the climate crisis increases and the harm to ourselves, the environment, business, industry and the economy that will follow, so a desire to not only reduce carbon but to be seen reducing carbon increases.

Two seemingly interchangeable terms often seen are carbon neutral and net-zero carbon.

The two, however, are not the same thing.

Carbon neutral refers to a policy of not increasing carbon emissions and of achieving carbon reduction through offsets. While net-zero carbon means making changes to reduce carbon emissions to the lowest amount - and offsetting as a last resort. The offsetting is used to counteract the essential emissions that remain after all available reduction initiatives have been implemented.

In both cases, carbon offsetting removes CO2 from the environment. For it to count, that removal must be permanent and accredited or licensed. Projects can offer a range of benefits. As well as reducing carbon from the atmosphere, offset projects can be selected to also offer social and community benefits. Projects can range from local planting of trees to the funding of projects that empower families in developing countries to reduce their dependence on fossil fuels. Examples include afforestation, reforestation and conservation. Alternative investments can also be made in initiatives that reduce greenhouse gas emissions, such as in cattle feed that reduces the methane output of cows.

Other offsetting projects enhance biodiversity, improve soil quality, food production or rainwater absorption. Projects that benefit soil quality are particularly pertinent to global warming and climate change, as soil is a significant store of carbon, holding three times as much carbon as the atmosphere - and the importance of soil quality has often been overlooked. Food production benefits are relevant too, given that crop failure is a significant negative impact of climate change, devastating communities and forcing migration.

 

Image

Picture: a photograph of Dr Torill Bigg 

 

The Importance of a Quantifiable Carbon Footprint

 

There are carbon offset schemes offered that are sold on an arbitrary average carbon footprint basis, as opposed to a quantified footprint. The risk with these is that they offer the temptation of an easy-to-buy option, which not only does not include any emission reductions they also may fail to meet sufficient offset to address the problem of climate change. These are sold on the basis that a true quantification of your carbon footprint can be expensive, time-consuming and complicated but this need not be the case.

Net-zero carbon commitments always involve emission reductions. This requires an initial carbon footprint measurement. This is followed by strategic greenhouse gas emission reduction initiatives, the implementation of renewable energy solutions and then carbon offsetting.

The right carbon reduction service can offer you all of these. Furthermore, they can support you in your net-zero commitment with ongoing monitoring both of the success of the initiatives but also of emerging technologies for further emission reduction opportunities. These could be in the form of technology, or availability of alternative energy - or internal opportunities from changes in processes, or collaborative opportunities with your supply chain. Potential opportunities could arise with local business partners such as neighbouring manufacturing facilities with whom you may be able to trade reused processed heat or reuse or repurpose materials. For example, could your carbon cardboard waste be shredded to become their packaging material or could waste heat from your processes be used for their hot water or offices?

This sort of methodical, structured and quantified approach leads to more optimised use of resources, lowers energy bills, reduces waste, reduces reliance on the national grid, delivers true reductions in emissions and so true reduced harm to the environment.

This article was written by Dr Torill Bigg, Chief Carbon Reduction Engineer, Tunley Engineering

Picture: a photograph of a protest sign at Marble Arch, London. The sign reads: "Love and protect our beautiful earth"

Article written by Dr Torill Bigg | Published 16 August 2021

Share



Related Articles

What Technologies are Essential for the Fight Against Climate Change?

April 22 marks Earth Day, a worldwide event that aims to diversify, educate and activate the environmental movement. Could technology play a key role in the fight against...

 Read Full Article
Green Gothenburg Moves on Net-Zero Transport Goal

Currently in development, Gothenburg Green City Zone is a world first as an initiative by a number of major stakeholders including Volvo Cars to build a...

 Read Full Article
Islay Distillery Targets Net-Zero with Hydrogen Innovation

Protium Green Solutions, the UK‐based green hydrogen energy services company, has received more than £70,000 in funding to complete a...

 Read Full Article
What Impact Will Climate Change Have on the Security Industry? – Part One

Despite the security sector not being a key industry contributing to carbon emissions, it is expected to face significant impacts due to climate change affecting the...

 Read Full Article
BM Celebrates Planet Mark Accreditation for Third Year


BM has been awarded Planet Mark accreditation for a third successive year after it achieved a 26 per cent absolute carbon reduction, and committed to a further five...

 Read Full Article
Global Recycling Day 2022 in FM

This year's Global Recycling Day took place on 18 March and celebrated the "recycling fraternity", those who put themselves on the frontline to...

 Read Full Article
How Can FMs Tackle Scope 3 Emissions?

The Sustainable Facilities Management Index has released the first part of an FM industry standardised approach to measuring carbon emissions. This includes the full...

 Read Full Article
Executives Invited to Join the World's-First Antarctic Climate Expedition

Aurora Expeditions is calling for applications to join the world-first Antarctic Climate Expedition in 2023, led by renowned oceanographer, marine biologist, explorer and...

 Read Full Article
Are Businesses Ready for Clean Air Zones?

On the eve of the extension of London’s Ultra Low Emission Zone (ULEZ) on 25 October, new data suggests not all businesses are ready, or are even aware of all the...

 Read Full Article
Sodexo Commits to Carbon Neutrality by 2025

Sodexo has raised its sustainability targets after cutting its carbon footprint by 34 per cent, ahead of schedule. Sodexo has laid out its net-zero roadmap after...

 Read Full Article