The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Thursday, 22 August

If You Buy Cheap, You Buy Twice

While taking a faulty bargain kettle back to the shop can prove an inconvenience, cutting corners in procuring long term service contracts can have a significant and lasting impact on a business, say the people at Gritit Grounds Maintenance.

Tales of poor service and squabbles over what’s in and out of scope in years two and three of service delivery are all too common and it’s invariably true that such issues often arise from a poor procurement process.

As competitive pressures ratchet up the need to do more with less, businesses will always seek new ways to make budgets stretch further, yet buying services also has to provide businesses with the flexibility to respond to new challenges.

 

Hot and cold

In outdoor FM services, the extremes of hot and cold weather over the past year is a case in point. Last winter was one of the UK’s coldest and harshest in years, creating huge demand for professional winter gritting and snow clearance services to keep sites safe and open for business. This was followed by a long, hot, dry summer that provided new challenges in planning and delivering effective grounds maintenance as the grass dried out and the hedges grew more rapidly.

 

Staying within budget

So, with the natural environment doing its bit to further tax the resources and budget allocated to outdoor FM services, how do you still stay within budget?

More importantly, how can one build the necessary responsiveness into the procurement process to ensure you buy services that are fit for purpose, sufficiently flexible and that don’t create unnecessary risk downstream?

Here are some essential tips to help balance these demands and succeed in procurement:

  • You’ve got to be 100% clear on what you need. Understand what 'good' looks like - buying a service is not the same as buying a product, so your specification needs to be as explicit as possible about your requirements, expectations and measurement. A vague specification will inevitably lead to inconsistent pricing from potential service partners due to varying interpretations of service requirements; this naturally favours suppliers who choose to assume that the minimum level applies and price accordingly.

  • Give some real thought to what’s important to you and make sure your procurement process is designed to consider those things. It’s amazing how often the pre-amble in tender documents talks about what’s important to an organisation but there is no reference to these elements in the tender questions.  If sustainability is a key driver, you need to evaluate the credentials of your potential service providers in the tender process.

  • Asking tender questions that tell you what you need to know whilst meeting the obligation to do an 'apples for apples' comparison is a bit of a dark art.  For high value complex requirements, it may be worth engaging a specialist procurement consultant; this will help to ensure that your process delivers the best possible outcome in terms of both quality and price.

  • Finally and most importantly of all, think really carefully about the evaluation weightings between cost and quality.  If the weightings are skewed toward cost you will inevitably risk falling into the procurement equivalent of 'buying cheap, buying twice' trap. Even at 60% cost/40% quality the lowest price will always win, which may be appealing in the here and now, but you need to consider if the cheapest price will be sustainable over the life of the contract.  If you really want a quality solution, you need to give it a higher rating and use the specification to make your requirements fit the budget.

 

Buying time

We are now entering the main buying season for grounds maintenance services and this is the time to start pulling your tender together. This is also the best opportunity to really think about what you need from your service and how this will work within your budget. As well as talking to your key stakeholders and understanding their requirements, why not also consult with the potential supply chain, before you are in the confines of the tender process, to get a feel for the art of the possible from the experts.  This will enable you to accurately articulate your requirements in the tender process and facilitate an evaluation of cost against comparable service levels. Taking this step will allow you to shape a process that can still reveal the providers that are able to deliver the service at a lower cost – or even the lowest cost. It will also ensure that you can understand how that pricing is being achieved. After all, there’s nothing inherently bad about buying cheap, and if a lower cost is the result of better productivity and efficiency then this is truly the ideal outcome for all parties. That’s what good procurement looks like. 

For further advice contact the GRITIT team:

www.gritit.com

Telephone: 0800 0432 911

Email: info@gritit.com

 

Article written by Brian Shillibeer

Share



Related Articles

Building a Garden that Delights

A new BBC series helping amateur designers to take on a garden at the Royal Horticultural Society’s Chelsea Flower Show 2015 has been praised. The London...

 Read Full Article
Property Flood Resilience eBook Launches

A new Property Flood Resilience eBook has launched to provide businesses and home owners with over 40 real-life case studies from business and communities that have...

 Read Full Article
Flood Defences Protect 400 Jobs

James Walker's major manufacturing site at Cockermouth site in Cumbria has seen its flood defence system become fully operational. The firm’s is one of the...

 Read Full Article
Don't Let Driving Cause The Summertime Blues

The RAC is urging drivers to check their vehicles before setting out in the heat - and to be aware that heat can cause tiredness and tiredness can increase the likelihood...

 Read Full Article
Therm Welfare - Heatwave & Skin Cancer Warnings

As the Met Office warns that temperatures could climb even higher than first forecast, Cancer Research UK has revealed  that skin cancer rates have rocketed by 45%...

 Read Full Article
We're All Going On A Summer Holiday?

As the school holidays get started and the sun comes out to shine, the TUC have claimed that 2 million workers are not getting their legal holiday entitlement. And...

 Read Full Article
Summertime - Make The Living More Easy

Bosses and facilities managers have been urged to allow flexible working, even on a temporary basis, as temperatures threaten to hit 37oC. The Trades Union Congress -...

 Read Full Article
Downpours Bring The Roof Down

June 24 saw the Met Office warn of heavy storms - and almost as the alerts went out, Stirling University and the local Tesco felt the full force of nature. The...

 Read Full Article
Fear Of Flooding - Water Damage Is £Billion Threat

Property owners must prepare for the worst is the latest stark warning from the UK Environment Agency, which suggests that £1 billion a year might be needed to be...

 Read Full Article
Climate Change Denier Blames Computer Warming Predictions

A leading climatologist has said that the computer simulations that are used to predict global warming are failing on a key measure of the climate today and cannot be...

 Read Full Article