- Content
- News
- Museum of London Site Should be Retrofitted not Demolished says Heritage Group
07 June 2023 | Updated 13 June 2023
Plans to build office blocks on the former Museum of London site have been criticised by campaign group Barbican Quarter Action, who say the existing building should be retrofitted instead.
The proposals to the London Wall West site include flexible, high-quality office spaces, new public spaces and improvements to walkways.
Barbican Quarter Action argue that the assertion that Bastion House is at risk of disproportionate collapse and thus not safe for retrofit and reuse is misleading. They commissioned two reports to show that the City of London’s London Wall West (LWW) proposal’s carbon assessment of the new project falls short as it does not consider the retention and retrofit of Bastion House and ignores the impact of its demolition on the scheme’s carbon footprint.
Simon Sturgis from Targeting Zero who co-authored the reports argues that “a more comprehensive retrofit approach than the one proposed, with Bastion House retained and retrofitted, would have far lower carbon emissions…”
The Museum of London has occupied the building on the edge of the Barbican for 47 years, and the site includes the 17-storey tower Bastion House.
The museum will move to a new site at West Smithfield, intending to open to the public as a visitor attraction in 2026.
City of London’s Carbon Assessment “Falls Short”
The LWW proposal states that “reuse of Bastion House is not considered feasible from an engineering perspective on account of the risk of disproportionate collapse which arises from the unique transfer structure and column design at level 3 of Bastion House” (WLCA 4.2.3).
Barbican Quarter Action’s reports demonstrate that only buildings using the Large Panel System of construction are at such risk and that Bastion House is not built using the LPS system.
Bob Stagg of Conisbee Structural Engineering reported that Bastion House and the Museum of London comply with all current building regulations and the buildings are in better condition than many other concrete buildings of that era. He also argues that the LWW team chose to consider and compare only two options: complete demolition and a part retention option – both of which include the demolition of Bastion House.
Shelagh Wright, part of Barbican Quarter Action told The Times newspaper: “Bastion House is a perfectly sound building. Why waste the carbon in knocking it down and building something new where there’s a building there that could be reused?”
In April 2023, the City of London Corporation announced that it would invite developers to explore retrofit options. That application period is now closed and it is as yet unknown if any alternative proposals were made.
Picture: a photograph of the Museum of London site at the western end of the London Wall. Image Credit: Adobe Stock
Article written by Ella Tansley | Published 07 June 2023
Share
Related Articles
New Scottish National Centre for Retrofit of Traditional Buildings Announced
A new national centre dedicated to championing the retrofit of traditional buildings will be established in Scotland.
Historic Environment Scotland (HES), using...
Read Full Article
RIBA’s Reinvention Award Shortlist Revealed
RIBA has announced its shortlist for its 2024 Reinvention Award, celebrating the innovative reuse of existing buildings.
The award spotlights buildings that have used...
Read Full Article
Retrofit of 60 Queen Victoria Street to Go Ahead
Planning permission has been granted to retrofit a 180,000 sq ft office building in the City of London.
60 Queen Victoria Street was built in the late 1990s and...
Read Full Article
Plans Submitted for Major Edinburgh Office Retrofit
Plans to revamp the landmark Calton Square office will extend the building from 150,000 sqft to 200,000 sqft.
The retrofit project will provide a significant uplift in...
Read Full Article
Canary Wharf’s Revolving Door Retrofit Project
A revolving door manufacturer has completed several retrofit projects at the Canary Wharf Estate.
Boon Edam has retrofitted the entrance systems of some of the...
Read Full Article
The Retrofit Academy Launches Enhanced Membership Scheme
The Retrofit Academy has launched a new membership scheme offering lifelong learning software access and networking opportunities.
Launching in August,...
Read Full Article
Wates Appointed to Retrofit 410 Homes
Wates will undertake a retrofit programme for 410 homes over two years on behalf of not-for-profit housing group Orbit.
The PAS3025-compliant contract includes...
Read Full Article
Historic Environment Scotland’s Retrofit Project Halted
Plans to find a new home for Historic Environment Scotland’s archives have been halted due to the rising cost of materials and labour.
Archive House, an existing...
Read Full Article
Mace Appointed to New Bridge Street Office Retrofit
Developer Helical has appointed Mace as the main contractor on the soon-to-be-revamped 100 New Bridge Street.
Helical acquired the property in March 2022 and planning...
Read Full Article
UK Green Building Council Outlines Manifesto for Next UK Government
The UK Green Building Council has published its general election policy agenda, introducing long-term strategies for change in the built environment.
With a General...
Read Full Article