The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Unpaid Claims - Insurers Always Win

03 September 2019 | Updated 04 September 2019
 

New research has revealed that companies who take their insurers to court or public arbitration over non-payment of a claim only win in around one in three cases.

The findings are from Mactavish, an adviser on commercial insurance governance and disputes, which reviewed every UK court case or arbitration appeal relating to payments under primary business insurance policies (excluding consumer and reinsurance cases) between 2013 and 2019.  Over this period, just 32% of decisions went in the policyholder’s favour.

Mactavish’s research found the sector most involved in public disputes with their insurers was construction, followed by manufacturing and transportation. For construction specific cases, only 25% of decisions were won by policyholders.

 

Unfavourable terms

The majority of disputes that organisations have with their insurers are settled through private arbitration, primarily because of unfavourable (and generally unchallenged) policy terms that limit the policyholder’s options in the event of their insurer disputing a claim.

Mactavish estimates that on average it takes around three years for disputes to be resolved and where settlements are made, they tend to be for around 60% of the original amount claimed. 

 

Cover

The main causes of insurance disputes are whether the loss is covered by the policy at all, followed by how the value of the loss should be calculated.  Secondary causes of dispute are breaches of policy conditions and inadequate risk disclosure.  There is also a growing trend for insurers to dispute claims because there has been late or incomplete notification from the client.

Bruce Hepburn, CEO of Mactavish said: “Our findings are disturbing for organisations that are looking to challenge their insurer’s decision not to pay-out on a claim when they perceive the decision to be unfair.  However, hiring professional consultants to help in this area can greatly enhance your chances of success – both to prevent disputes arising when handling a claim and to resolve them if they do.”

 

Resolution management

Mactavish offers a range of insurance governance services to organisations including analysis and the development of a resolution strategy for a potential or actual dispute with insurers. This is as an alternative to formal litigation or arbitration. Combining Mactavish’s policy wording, insurance law and commercial negotiation skills with targeted legal analysis by expert insurance barristers to assess the validity of the points in dispute, the service aims to negotiate and agree claims settlement rapidly.

Picture: Mactavish estimates that on average it takes around three years for disputes to be resolved and where settlements are made, they tend to be for around 60% of the original amount claimed. ​

 

Article written by Brian Shillibeer | Published 03 September 2019

Share



Related Articles

How To Kill Your Boss - The Most Googled Workplace Queries Revealed

Bullying, pregnancy and leaving their company are the most common topics UK workers search for when Googling questions about their boss - oh and how to kill them comes up...

 Read Full Article
Megatrends - Globalisation And Building Services

In the last of its series of four 'Megatrends' White Papers, BSRIA has explored how globalisation is affecting almost every aspect of life and business - and...

 Read Full Article
Signing-in Book - Sneaky Peekers Check Who's Already There

If a traditional signing-in book is in use, 62 per cent of those visiting or working in an office check out who’s checked in before them. So says new research by...

 Read Full Article
Rethinking Outsourcing - Local Government In Throes Of U-turn?

There is a declining appetite for outsourcing in local government according to research from the New Local Government Network which is calling for a rethink in...

 Read Full Article
Have Your Say in the UK Net-Zero Business Census

ThisWeekinFM Partner Planet Mark has launched its UK Net-Zero Business Census, the largest private sector sustainability research initiative of its kind. Delivered by...

 Read Full Article
Largest UK Employee Diversity Survey Outcomes Revealed

A survey of over 526,000 people working in the built environment has revealed ongoing challenges in the sector’s progress in making an inclusive environment that is...

 Read Full Article
Average Tradesperson Loses Out on Over £1,400 a Year Working at ‘Mates Rates’

A survey of tradespeople in the UK shows that they lose an average of over £1,400 a year doing work for free, or at reduced rates, for friends and relatives. 500...

 Read Full Article
Insights from RICS UK Facilities Management Survey

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors has published its latest quarterly FM survey, which collects data from facilities managers, service providers and FM...

 Read Full Article
IWFM Outlook Survey Reveals Challenges in FM Sector

The IWFM’s Market Outlook Survey 2022 finds challenges of supply chain squeezes, creeping inflation and a skills shortage of frontline workers. Each year,...

 Read Full Article
Lloyds of London Considers HQ Move From Iconic Building

Lloyds, the world’s largest insurance market, is considering moving from its 1 Lime Street headquarters, a site it has occupied since 1986. A spokesman for...

 Read Full Article