The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Rethinking Outsourcing - Local Government In Throes Of U-turn?

From Transactions To Changemaking Rethinking Partnerships Between The Public And Private Sectors
11 October 2018 | Updated 12 October 2018

There is a declining appetite for outsourcing in local government according to research from the New Local Government Network which is calling for a rethink in partnerships between the public and private sectors.

A survey of council leaderships found only 15 per cent saying they intend to outsource more over the next two years. 39 per cent say they will outsource less over the next two years, while 46 per cent indicate no change from current levels.

Financial and demand pressures, combined with recent high-profile failures such as the collapse of Carillion, mean the public sector in general is increasingly seeking more influence over partnerships, according to ‘From Transactions To Changemaking: Rethinking Partnerships Between The Public And Private Sectors' the latest report form the New Local Government Network (NLGN) which also features the results of the survey.



The NLGN is calling for reforms to boost oversight of the private sector; empower the public sector to drive long term value through partnerships; and ultimately boost public confidence over future partnerships.

This dwindling confidence in outsourcing suggests that councils are seeking greater control over service delivery arrangements, driven by funding and demand pressures, says the NLGN which also claims evidence also shows that councils are increasingly exploring new, innovative forms of partnerships such as trading companies and joint ventures. Meanwhile, again according to the NLGN, government departmental spend on outsourcing is still growing, although the backlash after high profile failures such as Carillion’s collapse has dented public confidence in partnership arrangements.


Outsourcing versus in-house

The NLGN’s report argues that the picture is more mixed than the simplistic outsourcing versus in-house debate that is emerging between the Conservative Government and the Labour Party. The study concludes that there is a need to reform how partnerships work in practice to make sure they are less transactional and more geared towards delivering genuine social impact for public spending.

The report also calls on Government to recognise that partnerships with the private sector are not a solution to funding reductions. In fact, cuts to the public sector have undermined the capacity and expertise available to drive value through partnerships, claim the NLGN.


Offering a blueprint for a new approach to partnerships between the public and the private sector, the report outlines a package of measures including:

  • Increasing the public oversight of the private sector through a new accountability code of conduct as well as a social responsibility accreditation system for all contracts over £200,000 and open book accounting on large contracts over £1 million.
  • Boosting the ability of the public sector to drive long term value through partnerships by replacing Social Value with a stronger measure of social impact. For example, public sector commissioning bodies should be able to enforce payment of the living wage through all contracts or the public sector will pick up the costs of low pay elsewhere in the system.
  • A new Government-backed review into improving transparency over private sector contracts for public services, to ensure data on cost, quality and performance is openly available.


Missing the point

On launching the report on October 10, Adam Lent, Director of the New Local Government Network, said: “Our findings show that the public sector is already rethinking its relationship to the private sector. But the current national political debate is missing the point. The Conservative Government takes a business as usual approach to outsourcing, while the Labour Party advocates taking everything back in house. Our research finds that it is not a question of more or fewer partnerships but establishing better ones. With new measures to boost oversight, make contract performance more transparent and to enhance the social return on public investment, partnerships will be fit for purpose for today’s challenges.”

Simon Goacher, partner and head of local government at national law firm Weightmans added: “If enacted, the report’s recommendations should help local government generate greater value from private sector partnerships and make the measurement of their social impact simpler. However, we should remember the onus isn’t just on Whitehall to deliver this change. The blueprint outlined by The NLGN here should encourage local government to build on existing good practice in the commissioning of public service already observed by many councils. Avoiding transactional, cost driven procurement is a great first step. But this should be accompanied by a change of thinking that pins down exactly what’s needed to make a contract a success from the outset.

“This means taking the time to canvas the opinions of key stakeholders within the community and incorporating their measures of success into a bespoke, transparent procurement process.”

NLGN’s research was conducted in partnership with ENGIE, Jacobs and Weightmans.

Picture: From Transactions To Changemaking Rethinking Partnerships Between The Public And Private Sectors.

Article written by Brian Shillibeer | Published 11 October 2018


Related Articles

How To Kill Your Boss - The Most Googled Workplace Queries Revealed

Bullying, pregnancy and leaving their company are the most common topics UK workers search for when Googling questions about their boss - oh and how to kill them comes up...

 Read Full Article
Megatrends - Globalisation And Building Services

In the last of its series of four 'Megatrends' White Papers, BSRIA has explored how globalisation is affecting almost every aspect of life and business - and...

 Read Full Article
Unpaid Claims - Insurers Always Win

New research has revealed that companies who take their insurers to court or public arbitration over non-payment of a claim only win in around one in three cases. The...

 Read Full Article
Outsourcing - Grid Iron Not Gridlock - Playbook Launched

An 'Outsourcing Playbook' has been published by the Cabinet Office - a Playbook is expected to contain all the pieces and parts that make up an organisation's...

 Read Full Article
Signing-in Book - Sneaky Peekers Check Who's Already There

If a traditional signing-in book is in use, 62 per cent of those visiting or working in an office check out who’s checked in before them. So says new research by...

 Read Full Article
The UK Public Sector’s Top FM Suppliers

Find out which facilities management companies are leading the way in public sector contracts with Tussell's “Meet the FM Titans”...

 Read Full Article
Government Hub in Birmingham Awarded Leesman+ Certification

The Government Property Agency’s Birmingham Hub offers the best employee workplace experience in the UK’s public sector. 23 Stephenson Street in Birmingham...

 Read Full Article
Boeing Aircrafts to Cut 2,000 Office Workers

Boeing intends to refocus on engineering and manufacturing this year, cancelling around 2,000 current employment contracts mostly held in finance and...

 Read Full Article
Applications Open for £135 Million Public Sector Building Maintenance and Compliance Framework

LHC, the not-for-profit public sector construction framework provider, has launched a framework to support building maintenance and compliance in the public...

 Read Full Article
Bidvest Noonan Security Staff Strike At UCL Over Pay

Outsourced security staff have been striking at University College London this week, in a protest over pay. Over 150 people attended the strike on Monday 14 November,...

 Read Full Article