The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

BESA Tightens Security After Fraud Incident

Security Online
28 March 2022 | Updated 29 March 2022

The Building Engineering Services Association (BESA) says it has carried out a thorough review of the security procedures behind its online training schemes following the jailing of two construction skills testers last month.

The two men were jailed for 28 months each after pleading guilty to charges that they falsified CITB health, safety and environment tests used to assess whether a worker is qualified to carry a skills card needed to work on UK construction sites.

CITB investigators said they had uncovered a large-scale criminal operation that was helping mainly foreign nationals get through the safety tests to qualify for the Construction Skills Certification Scheme (CSCS) cards, which are used by site managers to verify the training and qualifications of all site workers. 

In some cases, the exams were undertaken by the administrators on behalf of the candidates, or they were able to feed them the answers during their tests. Prosecutors said the case had put members of the public and other construction workers at risk by allowing unqualified people onto sites. Many of these workers may also have been trafficked by criminal gangs.

The scale of the fraud prompted BESA’s acclaimed online training Academy to carry out a swift review of its test verification procedures to reassure employers and test candidates.


“The fraud prosecutions were a timely reminder that we must do everything possible to protect this hugely valuable system from a minority who seek to undermine it.”


– Helen Yeulet
Director of Training & Skills, BESA


Protortrack Monitoring


BESA uses a system called Proctortrack to regulate and monitor its online testing. This has controls in place that, for example, prevent the use of any other application while undertaking a test or exam, including the use of a remote mouse.

“The Proctortrack system recognizes over 430 applications and background processes and the list is constantly being updated,” said the Association’s director of training and skills Helen Yeulet.  “Any student using an app outside of that list, or any unauthorised window that is found to be open during an exam will be instantly detected and reported as an online aid.”

The system can also monitor any background audio which would flag up if a student was being given help or was communicating with someone else during an exam, she added.

Proctortrack uses a zoomed video frame which allows it to capture the full view from the student’s webcam so anyone to the side of the student will be seen. It also reviews student behaviour and facial expressions to flag any suspicious activity. 

The BESA Academy has a list of violations picked up by this process including students looking away from the screen for more than three seconds or at devices other than their laptop. It has also experienced the use of imposters and other people being present while the individual is taking their test.

Accessing course materials on a separate screen is another violation picked up by the Proctortrack system as well as the use of emails to read course information.


Compliance is a Priority 


“The vast majority of people undertaking our tests do so honestly, but we are always vigilant to make sure we catch those who try to cut corners,” said Yeulet. “We have been reassured by our review of the Proctortrack system that everything humanly and technologically possible is being done to protect the integrity of our schemes.

“It is particularly important that health & safety testing is underpinned by a robust verification process to keep workers and the public safe – any violations will automatically lead to the student failing the test.”

Yeulet said the expansion of online training and testing, and its growing sophistication and flexibility were proving to be a major benefit to the building services industry by making it easier for more people to improve their knowledge and skills.

“The fraud prosecutions were a timely reminder that we must do everything possible to protect this hugely valuable system from a minority who seek to undermine it,” she added.


Picture: a person at their computer with a "security" caption superimposed above them. Image credit: Pixabay.

Article written by Bailey Sparkes | Published 28 March 2022


Related Articles

BESA Calls for Compromise in Safety Insurance Row

Contractors and insurers must work together to ensure the rising cost of professional indemnity insurance does not undermine efforts to improve building safety, according...

 Read Full Article
BESA Launches Associate Membership Scheme

BESA has launched a new membership category catering for individuals with a particular interest in the building services industry. This is a significant development...

 Read Full Article
Clean Air Day 2020 – BESA Calls for Greater Focus on Indoor Air Quality

Clean Air Day is the UK's largest air pollution campaign, engaging thousands of people at hundreds of events, and reaching millions more through the media. The...

 Read Full Article
BESA Launches Online Training Academy

The Building Engineering Services Association has opened its new online academy delivering a comprehensive programme of training courses, assessments and CPD for...

 Read Full Article
Environment Bill Should Give Councils Air Quality Powers

Local councils should be given the legal authority to enforce higher standards of air quality in schools, public buildings and homes according to the Building Engineering...

 Read Full Article
Nice People Come Last at Christmas

An HSBC report says fraud victims (especially during the festive season) are 10 per cent ‘nicer’ than those who’ve not suffered at the hands of...

 Read Full Article
Gangsters' Paradise Leads To Jail Terms For Business Phishing Scam

Gangsters who altered business emails to rip-off more than £1 million have gone to jail. Two members of the Nigerian organised crime group who committed the fraud...

 Read Full Article
Adam Taylor Named as New BESA Indoor Air Quality Chair

The new chair of the Indoor Air Quality group of the Building Engineering Services Association has been elected. Adam Taylor, CEO of ARM Environments will...

 Read Full Article
Building Control Officer Competence Deadline Extended by HSE

Building control professionals in England have received a 13-week extension to allow them more time to complete competence assessments. The Director of Building Safety...

 Read Full Article
BESA Urges Building Services Employers to Reset Their Approach to Recruitment

BESA’s Director of Training and Skills believes more companies need to “step up and walk the walk by committing to take on more apprentices.” Helen...

 Read Full Article