The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Government Risks Stalling EV Growth With Outdated Systems, Says Mina

14 November 2022

The government is out of touch with the cost of running EVs, and as a result, drivers are having to subsidise business trips themselves, research from charging payment specialist Mina has found.

Its CEO, Ashley Tate, has warned that unless there is a change to the way drivers are reimbursed for business miles many employees, when they realise they are paying for trips out of their own pocket, are likely to refuse to use EVs, slowing the transition to electric.


Business Mileage Rates Must be Updated


HMRC’s Advisory Electricity Rate (AER), which is a simplistic flat rate for paying back business mileage, has remained the same - 5 pence per mile - since December 2021, despite electricity prices soaring in that time. 

Mina’s real-world data shows that this summer alone, home charging costs increased 30 per cent and public charging 19 per cent. As a result, 94 per cent of journeys charged at home cost more than the Government’s 5ppm rate, and 100 per cent of those charged in public cost the driver more than the AER.

In some cases, employees were out of pocket by as much as 17p per mile if they charged in public - equivalent to £17 over a 100-mile journey, or personally subsidising £1,700 over 10,000 miles a year.

Mina’s data from its EV Report - Summer 22 shows that on average charging from home is cheaper at 9ppm (compared to than in public, at 20ppm) but at that figure, drivers are missing out by 4ppm, which equates to £4 for a 100-mile journey. At 10,000 business miles a year, that same driver has paid out £400 of their own money for business travel. 

Ashley Tate, Mina CEO and Co-Founder, said: “Businesses account for around two-thirds of all EVs on the road, but the Government is risking the success of the transition to electric with the outdated method of paying these hard-working drivers. Those already in EVs will want to know why they are personally subsidising their business travel, while employees about to make the switch to electric may refuse once they realise they will be losing financially on every work trip they make.

“Our data shows that the AER is completely unfit for purpose, because it just does not reflect the cost of real-life electric driving. It was out-of-date just before it increased to 5ppm in December 2021, with 78 per cent of charges costing more than the AER at the time, and is even more so now. As energy prices rise this winter, this disconnect will become greater. As drivers come to realise this, it is likely to have a serious impact on the transition to electric vehicles.

Employers can offer to pay more than the advisory rate but in order to do this and not incur any benefit-in-kind tax on that extra amount, they have to prove why they have used their own rate with evidence of each charge. 

“The issue is that charging is not a simplistic, one-size-fits all process, as filling a tank with petrol and diesel is. Homeowners are all on varying tariffs, and within those tariffs the costs can be different at different times of the day,” said Ashley.

“Then, in public, charging networks all have vastly different rates - our figures show they can vary from free, to 30 p per kWh as the cheapest paid-for rate, and up to £2.77 if things like parking are included. How is a business going to show to HMRC what is a reasonable rate when there are so many different factors involved? It would be a vast statistical undertaking.”

Mina tracks all charging at home, and within its public charging network, so that it knows exactly what an employee is paying for electricity every time they plug in. That means it can assign the real amount for private and business to every charge so the employee’s charging costs are always paid for accurately.

Because it is all recorded and paid direct to the supplier automatically, there is far less administration for both business and employee and far more accuracy. Crucially, the system is approved by HMRC too, so there’s no benefit in kind to pay on rates above the AER.

“The transition to electric is undoubtedly a good thing for individuals, businesses, the economy and the environment, but to do it well and do it properly requires new ways of operating. As our figures prove, simplistic, blunt instruments such as the AER don’t work. 

“And it won’t work - no matter how much HMRC raises the figure - in this more complex cost environment with its many different vehicle types, tariffs and charges. But our innovative solution, which takes all of this into account, makes paying for EV charging radically simple, and crucially, fair,” he added.

To download a copy of Mina’s EV Report - Summer 22, click here


Visit Mina at EMEX 2022 – Stand D45


Mina’s multi award winning payment solution for EV charging is the UK’s only platform which allows fleet and business electric vehicles to be charged at home and on the road, resulting in a single monthly invoice for the business.

Powering some of the largest electric fleets in the UK, Mina Homecharge® accurately pays the employees' energy supplier for the cost of charging their company EV at home and with Mina Chargepass®, employees can charge in the UK’s fastest roaming network dedicated to businesses – this includes all charge points within the Allstar and InstaVolt networks.

Businesses are able to see key insights including carbon intensity and emissions, cost per kWh, location and duration of each charge across their fleet in our easy-to-use Fleet Portal.

This makes paying for EV charging transparent, accurate and simple for employers and employees.

This year, Mina is exhibiting alongside their partners, EQUANS – Visit stand C70 and D45 to find out how they can support your business.

Click here to register for your free ticket for EMEX 2022.

Picture: a photograph of a person using an electric charging station. Image Credit: Pexels

Article written by Mina | Published 14 November 2022


Related Articles

Equans  – EMEX 2022 | Focus Interview

Equans enables businesses to transition to net-zero carbon through their EV Solutions business, whether it’s a few chargers for the workplace or the...

 Read Full Article
SEE Services Assists Yorkshire Ambulance Service in EV Upgrades

SEE Services is working with the Yorkshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust to support the setting up of its electric vehicle charging infrastructure. With more electric...

 Read Full Article
Compleo Launches New High-Power 200 kW EV Charger

EV charging manufacturer Compleo has unveiled its 200 kW ultra-fast electric vehicle charger. The eTower 200 can deliver 200 kW ultra-fast charging for two vehicles...

 Read Full Article
Government Increases Electric Car Charging Grants for Schools

The Department for Transport has announced that state schools will be able to apply for a grant to cover 75 per cent of the cost of buying and installing EV charging...

 Read Full Article
RAC Says Government’s Ultra-Rapid EV Charging Targets Have Failed

Targets for every motorway service station in England to have at least six rapid chargers above 50kW by the end of 2023 have failed, according to data from RAC and...

 Read Full Article
Maintenance Partners for EV Charger Network Needed

A UK EV charge point manufacturer is looking for new maintenance partners to service over 2,000 installations. Compleo Charging Solutions UK’s tender process...

 Read Full Article
TfL Electric Vehicle Charging Contact Awarded

Transport for London has awarded a contract for 39 new electric vehicle charging bays across 24 locations in south and southwest London. The charging bays will be...

 Read Full Article
Energy Assets Launches Net-Zero Business

Energy services company Energy Assets has launched “EA Net Zero” to help their customers adopt low-carbon technologies. Specialising in the industrial and...

 Read Full Article
Mitie Wins Job Centre EV Charging Contract

The Department for Work and Pensions has awarded Mitie a contract to install 250 new electric vehicle charging points at job centres across the UK. The £4.3...

 Read Full Article
Datore  – EMEX 2022 | Focus Interview

Datore is a business intelligence platform that provides visual analytics and AI solutions to allow companies to optimise their energy usage and sustainability...

 Read Full Article