The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

What Went Wrong With London’s Tulip Skyscraper?

What Went Wrong With London’s Tulip Skyscraper?
19 November 2021

The high-tech skyscraper next to the Gherkin was supposed to be a new urban square for Londoners, but the government has rejected plans for its construction.

The Tulip would have been the tallest building in the City of London and the second highest in the capital, after The Shard.

Housing Secretary Michael Gove’s lengthy decision letter describes several concerns including disrupting the balance of heritage and modern buildings, the proposed use of unseasonable building materials and the potential to disrupt views of nearby heritage sites.

The 12-story building was initially approved by the City of London Corporation, but then rejected by Mayor Sadiq Khan.

The Foster & Partners development cited itself as a sustainable asset to London’s skyline, with a new education facility for the use of London state schools. So, what went wrong?


Watch the Video



Disrupting Views of Heritage Assets


One major stumbling block for The Tulip was its domination on London’s skyline.

David Nicholson RIBA IHBC, an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, concluded that on the walk across Tower Bridge, the Tulip would appear to move right the way through the airspace behind the White Tower and this would be “highly apparent and intrusive to the viewer.”

He also stated that the open sky around the White Tower would be “severely affected” by the Tulip and would disrupt the sensitive balance between the City and the world heritage site.

An appeal argued that the scheme’s public benefits demonstrably outweigh any specific alleged heritage harm. However, The Secretary of State decided that the heritage harm would not be outweighed by the public benefits of the proposal.

It was decided that there would be additional harm to the settings of other designated heritage assets, notably the church of St Botolph without Aldgate, 10 Trinity Square and Trinity House


Unsustainable Use of Concrete


Despite the project aiming for a BREEAM rating of outstanding, the decision letter rules that the extensive measures that would be taken to minimise carbon emissions during construction would not outweigh the highly unsustainable concept of using vast quantities of reinforced concrete for the foundations and lift shaft.

Foster & Partners, member of the Low Carbon Concrete Group of the Green Construction Board, argued that the material choice was a key part of the design process and that concrete would reduce embodied energy by 31 per cent compared with steel.



Picture: a photograph giving a bird's eye view of the Tulip and Gherkin


“A Lift Shaft With a Bulge”


The CEO of  Historic England called the attraction a lift shaft with a bulge” in 2019, citing its impact on the Tower of London

Historic England has welcomed the rejection decision, saying that they have long been of the opinion that The Tulip would be visually intrusive and highly incongruous from key viewpoints of the Tower, detracting from the experience of visiting the site for millions of tourists and Londoners.

It is also their view that it would harm the significance of the Tower of London as a World Heritage Site, and therefore the proposals ran contrary to local and national planning policies.




What Next?


Developer Bury Street Properties told The Guardian newspaper: “We are disappointed by the UK government’s decision to refuse planning permission for the Tulip.

“In our opinion, this project represented a unique opportunity to reaffirm London’s world-leading reputation in architecture, culture, education, and tourism.”

Judith Dupré, author of Skyscrapers, A History of the World's Most Extraordinary Buildings, questioned the future of skyscrapers themselves in a recent BBC article. She states that that height and design restrictions on new skyscrapers such as The Tulip might mean their golden age is over:

“Skyscrapers convey power, economic might, and technical prowess - attributes that are irresistible to nation builders.

“The pandemic has compelled more expansive thinking about tall buildings and the people who work in them, calling for flexibility, adaptability, access to nature, and towers that conserve more and consume less.”

Picture: a photograph of the exterior of the Tulip. Image Credit: The Tulip 

Article written by Ella Tansley | Published 19 November 2021


Related Articles

Holborn Viaduct Offices Application Approved

An office-led development that sits across two levels on Holborn Viaduct and Farringdon Street has been granted planning permission. Royal London Asset Management has...

 Read Full Article
City of London Corporation Wins Award for New Migration Museum

The City of London Corporation has won a planning award for its role in developing a new home for the Migration Museum in the Square Mile. Planning permission was...

 Read Full Article
AI Images Predict What London Skyline Will Look Like in 2030

The City of London Corporation has published new AI images that show the future skyline of the Square Mile, predicting what it will look like in 2030.   Watch...

 Read Full Article
First Square Mile Development to Use Closed Loop Cooling and Heating

The first geothermal borehole has been completed on the Salisbury Square Development, making it the first scheme in the Square Mile to use a standalone closed loop...

 Read Full Article
City of London to ‘Fast-Track’ Office Retrofits

The City of London is tackling the demand for high-grade office space by introducing a "retrofit fast-track" planning approach. A recommendation from...

 Read Full Article
New City Planning Guidance Will Require Detailed Carbon Information

Developers in the City of London will need to provide detailed carbon impact figures before submitting an application under new planning guidance. Under the advice...

 Read Full Article
City of London Consults Developers on Light Pollution Strategy

The City of London Corporation is looking to implement requirements that restrict how buildings are lit in the Square Mile. The draft Lighting Supplementary Planning...

 Read Full Article
Schroders Submits Planning Application for 55 Bishopsgate Redevelopment

Schroders Capital Real Estate team has submitted a planning application for a new skyscraper in the City of London. The proposed scheme looks to open up the area...

 Read Full Article
Will HSBC Leave its Iconic Canary Wharf Home?

Leaked memos suggest that the banking giant is considering whether to keep its global HQ at HSBC Tower when the lease expires in 2027. HSBC has occupied the 45-storey...

 Read Full Article
UK’s Largest 100% Electric Net-Zero Office Set For 2026

A £400 million development finance facility to fund 105 Victoria Street means building work will commence this year, with Skanska as the main contractor. Welput,...

 Read Full Article