The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Churchgoers Shaken from Above by a Bolt

19 February 2015 | Updated 01 January 1970

A Derbyshire company has been fined after a two-storey portable building collapsed while more than 30 children and parents were playing in the lower room.

South Derbyshire Magistrates’ Court heard the incident happened at Ashbourne Elim Pentecostal Church in Derbyshire while two volunteers – one of them partially sighted – were preparing parcels for the church’s foodbank in the upper cabin.

The two cabins had been refurbished and installed by Relocatable Building Systems in September 2013. A month later, on 24 October, both cabins dropped when a bolt on the jacking leg of the lower unit sheared off. The top part of the leg came out of the wooden frame, causing the collapse.

The upper cabin came to rest on the roof of the lower one at one corner, sending a number of food items falling off the shelves in the upper building. One of the volunteers suffered a bruised arm and although no one else was injured, all were badly shaken. Senior pastor, Rev Ben Brown said it was a ‘miracle’ the lower cabin had not collapsed on them.

A Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation found the company had refurbished the buildings before their installation at the church. New inner sections of the jacking legs were installed but the original pins, used to adjust the height of the legs, could not be fitted due to the holes not being drilled to the correct size. Instead, smaller bolts, which were not designed for this purpose, were used, meaning they would fail at some time in the future.

An Improvement Notice was served by HSE on Relocatable Building Systems, requiring the company to develop safe systems of work to ensure refurbished buildings were safe. Both cabins at the church were repaired and reinstalled.

Relocatable Building Systems Ltd, of Hilton Industrial Estate, Sutton Lane, Hilton, Derby was fined a total of £8,000 with £1,589 costs after admitting two breaches of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974.

“This was a terrifying incident for those involved and left a lot of people scared and upset,” stated Steve Shaw HSE Inspector after the hearing. “During installation the company should have carried out a final check to ensure all the work had been completed and the two cabins were bolted together safely. It is very lucky that the top cabin stayed in contact with three of the jacking legs as this prevented the full weight coming to rest on the wooden frame of the lower unit where children were playing. The wooden frames are not designed to take the weight of an upper unit, so it could have quite easily come crashing down with horrific consequences.

Mr Shaw went on to observe that the collapse could have been avoided by Relocatable Building Systems had the refurbishment been undertaken in a suitable manner, using the same or better specification material as the original.


Building back trust

Rev Ben Brown, asserted that the community’s “confidence in the church was destroyed through no fault of our own and we had to build that trust back up again. There is still some suspicion and a few people still refuse to go in the buildings, even though they’ve been back in place for over a year. There’s no doubt our relationship with the community suffered as a result of what happened.”

Pictured: Ashbourne Elim Pentecostal Church in Derbyshire, where a portable building collapsed in 2013.

Article written by Cathryn Ellis | Published 19 February 2015


Related Articles

Jail Time for Two Construction Killers

A construction manager has been jailed for gross negligence manslaughter, after a workman was crushed to death on a building site. Andrew Winterton, 52, was in charge...

 Read Full Article
Jail Time for Cost Cutting Killers. Whitbread in Hot Water Apology

Three company directors were jailed on May 19 following the death of a man who fell while working at a warehouse in Essex. Nikolai Valkov, 63, died in hospital after...

 Read Full Article
Safety Fines Reflect Size of Guilty Firms

A construction company has been fined £3/4 million for asbestos failings; another for a falling load crush; another for a trench collapse; and another for an...

 Read Full Article
Crick Institute Brings Death to London

Construction contractor CMF Ltd has been fined after a 31-year-old sub-contractor, Richard Laco, died when working on a large and prestigious construction project in...

 Read Full Article
Man Paralysed by Falling Pipes

An Essex company specialising in gas infrastructure have been fined after an employee suffered a serious injury when a pipe fell into the trench he was working in and...

 Read Full Article
Crushing Fine for Airport Death

A construction firm has been sentenced following the death of Philip Griffiths at Heathrow Airport in October 2014. Southwark Crown Court heard that Philip’s...

 Read Full Article
Falling Frames Kill Lawyer - Men Convicted

A man has been found guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence after a woman walking past a construction site died when three window frames weighing more than half a ton...

 Read Full Article
One Dead, One Injured in Lift Car Plunge Tragedy

A company and a self employed contractor have been fined for safety failings after one man died and another was left seriously injured falling six storeys through a lift...

 Read Full Article
Falls and Walls Cost Constructors

Construction company Kier Construction Limited has been fined £400,000 after a worker fell from height. Westminster Magistrates’ Court heard how Jair...

 Read Full Article
All in All Just Another Brick in The Wall?

The Report of the Independent Inquiry into the Construction of Edinburgh Schools has been published. It was commissioned by Chief Executive Andrew Kerr last summer after...

 Read Full Article