The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Corporate Law and the Sleight of Hand

08 March 2017 | Updated 01 January 1970

The Health and Safety Executive has settled a judicial review of its cost recovery process out of court before the planned High Court hearing on March 8.

The OCS Group (the massive international facilities management company - employing more than 87,000 people in 50 countries worldwide) was granted permission for the judicial review in September 2016. The matter under review was the process used by the HSE for handling challenges to its charges for visiting workplaces, under its Fee for Intervention (FFI) scheme.

FFI was introduced in October 2012 in an effort to pass the costs of health and safety monitoring and compliance on to businesses rather than have them paid for via taxation through funding of the HSE. In the case of disagreement over whether there were indeed safety breaches which triggered cost recovery or the level of those costs, a dispute resolution panel consisting of two HSE representatives and an independent person sat to decide the matter.


Not fair

“Our decision to ask for a judicial review of the Fee for Intervention dispute resolution process was not about opposing the idea of FFI but about addressing concerns we have about the independence, fairness and transparency of the dispute process in which HSE effectively acted as prosecution, judge and jury,” said Ian Goodlife, director of health, safety, quality and environmental at OCS Group.


Already agree

The Health and Safety Executive had already announced that it is to consult on proposals to make its cost recovery scheme dispute process fully independent (Click Here) but is now obliged to introduce its revised process for determining disputes on or before 1 September 2017.

Goodlife concluded: “OCS Group is a safety focussed organisation and we have a good working relationship with the Health and Safety Executive". Yet despite this posturing, the consent order entered into by both OCS Group and the HSE, sees the HSE forced to withdraw its August 2014 notice of contravention in which it alleged failures in the management of Hand Arm Vibration Syndrome (HAVS) by OCS Group staff using strimmers.

Picture: The HAVS and the HAVS not - no case to answer for OCS  

Article written by Brian Shillibeer | Published 08 March 2017


Related Articles

The Rights and Wrongs Of Prohibition Notices

The Supreme Court has recently decided that where a Prohibition Notice is served and subsequently found to be unfounded, the Notice can be rescinded or modified but the...

 Read Full Article
Dursley Does It - Fine For School Unlicensed Asbestos Removal

A company has been fined following an unlicensed asbestos removal from a school. The unsafe and unlicensed removal occurred during refurbishment works at Dursley...

 Read Full Article
Vehicle Crushes Pedestrian & Other Cases

A worker has been sentenced after seriously injuring pedestrian - we have the disturbing CCTV footage of the incident plus news of another six...

 Read Full Article
Up, Up And Away - Drones Drafted In For Building Inspections

The Sky has become the limit as a new partnership looks to take inspection strategy to, quite literally, a whole new level.   Against the backdrop of an...

 Read Full Article
NHS Trusts In The Dock - Legionella and Lone Worker Fatality Convictions

Royal United Hospitals (Bath) NHS Foundation Trust has (in week ending December 15) pleaded guilty to a charge under Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act...

 Read Full Article
Scaffolding - Dangers Exposed

Date: August 21 - Construction company fined after worker fell from height A construction company has been fined after a worker suffered life changing injuries after...

 Read Full Article
Bam Ferrovial Keir Fined £1 Million

A passenger air transport firm has been fined after an employee suffered brain damage after being crushed by hangar doors in Bedfordshire. St Albans Crown Court heard...

 Read Full Article
Illness and Injuries High Despite Death Rate Decline

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) released its annual figures for work related fatalities (April 2016 to March 2017)  on July 5, as well as a figure for the...

 Read Full Article
Explosion Sees Massive Fine - Plus Legal Digest

  This week saw a £1 million fine for a company after an oxygen pipe exploded during maintenance. A Sheffield Forgemasters Engineering Limited (SFEL)...

 Read Full Article
United in Government Call for End to Dangerous Deregulation

The UK Government has been urged to scrap its approach to deregulation of health and safety legislation in the light of the Grenfell Tower blaze. In an open letter to...

 Read Full Article