The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

NEC4 Contracts in FM – Q&A with Queen Margaret University

NEC4 Contracts in FM – Q&A with Queen Margaret University
20 July 2022

NEC4 contracts have been praised for their ability to foster greater collaboration. ThisWeekinFM spoke to the Head of Estates and Engineering at Queen Margaret University, and the team from SPACE, to understand their experience of the contract model.

The NEC4 Alliance Contract (ALC) was introduced in June 2018, and is known as a “true alliance arrangement in which the client and all key members of the supply chain are engaged under a single contract.”

Managed by a small FM team, Queen Margaret University (QMU), a campus with approximately 2,300 sqm of academic space and a similar size for accommodation, has partnered with SPACE FM to adopt an NEC contract system to operate their FM service delivery.

We interviewed John Walker, Head of Estates and Engineering at QMU and the SPACE team: Stuart Craig and Miguel Montenegro; to understand more about how the team handles their FM services and their experience of NEC.



Picture: a photograph of John Walker. Image Credit: QMU



What Do You See as the Main Challenges You and Your Team Face in Trying to Administer the FM Supply Chain to Support Educational Delivery at QMU?


John: QMU has a small in-house team and, consequently, our biggest challenge is accessing external skills and resources at the right time to support what we do. From the IFM contract point of view, our biggest challenge is administration, particularly with a new style of contract, so we concluded sourcing external support was the way to manage it all.  


"The other challenge has been to change mindsets when it comes to the IFM contract and ensuring we focus on what they are delivering rather than how. That has made a difference too."

–John Walker

Head of Estates and Engineering, Queen Margaret University


After two years of manually managing the NEC4 contract, which is very heavily process driven, SPACE recommended we implement CEMAR. Having a system that integrates the management of these processes is essential and that has been a challenge up until now but with the new CEMAR system in place and with the expertise of our SPACE colleagues, things are now running much more smoothly and reliably.

The other challenge has been to change mindsets when it comes to the IFM contract and ensuring we focus on what they are delivering rather than how. That has made a difference too.


What Were the Main Drivers That Shaped Your Decision to Pursue an Outsourced, Integrated FM (IFM) Approach to Service Delivery?


John: Where in the past we had a range of contractors supporting different elements of facilities, our thinking was that integrating all of these elements into one provider would eliminate multiple interfaces and further integrate that provider into the QMU team. This would be much more efficient and encourage cross-communication and cross-fertilisation of information and ideas.

Stuart: An integrated route is so much simpler, not least, because there is only one contract. However, efficiency and improved performance are key to this approach, so we worked together to create an optimal system.


Can You Tell us Why the NEC4 Contract Was Chosen as the Mechanism to Manage the Outsourced Contract?


Stuart: Our relationship was something that kind of grew, as these things often do. From the start it was clear that QMU was looking for integration and an NEC3 or 4 contract. NEC4 was fairly new in 2019, when we were discussing it, but as it’s the future of FM management, we went with it. We now have a clear operational framework.

Our initial role was to help scope out the integrated model and then handle the procurement process. We aimed to generate as much interest as possible in the market and then really engage with it, encouraging collaboration and negotiations through the process to ensure that what came out at the end was the best fit for both parties.

It was a worthwhile journey. And I like to think that at every stage we were able to demonstrate that we could work flexibly with potential suppliers and the estates team, adapting to QMU's needs. It has very much been a partnership between SPACE FM and QMU all the way through.


What Key Benefits Have Been Achieved From this Partnership and Working Relationship with Miguel at SPACE FM?


John: In the same way that we have been integrating the IFM Contractor into the QMU team the relationship with Miguel has been very similar. Having that single point of contact bringing the expertise, understanding and detail of NEC contracts and how they operate has been a huge benefit.

Miguel: Because of the structured nature of NEC contracts, knowing how to navigate them is essential for the best outcome, though they offer a safe methodology and a single point of contact, which is of great value.

Stuart: There are a lot of mechanisms which need to be followed correctly. Both parties need to manage the contract equally, so the advantages are also equal. If both parties are fully compliant with the requirements of the contract, then the outcomes will demonstrate the real benefit of an NEC contract.  When it’s done properly, it works really well.

John:  An additional benefit is that even though NEC is a formal contract between the parties, in line with the collaborative ethos of NEC4, this support has also been made available to the contractor, which has further improved the efficiency of administration.

Stuart: That's a good point you make. We were appointed by QMU, but Miguel would be just as willing to help out on the service side. It's not a case of having all the cards stacked in our favour, it’s more about making sure both parties are doing what needs to be done. Overall, the single point of contact, the right expertise and a knowledge of using NEC to best value is what really gets the job done well.

Picture: a photograph of the exterior of the QMU campus building. Image Credit: SPACE

Article written by Ella Tansley | Published 20 July 2022


Related Articles

High Performing Buildings – February's Roundup

This month’s high performing buildings roundup looks at shortlisted projects in the RIBA Regional Awards, which celebrate great architecture across the...

 Read Full Article
CBRE Wins Hard FM Contract at University of Glasgow

CBRE has been awarded a five-year contract to deliver planned and reactive hard facilities management services for the University of Glasgow.  The contract to...

 Read Full Article
EcoSync Close to £1m Funding Target for Commercial Building Energy Solution

A tech start-up that provides room-by-room energy management solutions for commercial buildings has raised close to £1 million in its second seed funding...

 Read Full Article
Bidvest Noonan Security Staff Strike At UCL Over Pay

Outsourced security staff have been striking at University College London this week, in a protest over pay. Over 150 people attended the strike on Monday 14 November,...

 Read Full Article
Sodexo’s Tom Martin Wins Young Leader of the Year Award

Tom Martin, Contract Manager for Student Living by Sodexo at Northumbria University, has been named Young Leader of the Year at the 2022 PFM awards. Tom joins a list...

 Read Full Article
NMITE Launches BSc Sustainable Built Environment Degree

Hereford’s New Model Institute for Technology and Engineering has launched a first-of-its-kind degree focused on the sustainable built environment. Coinciding...

 Read Full Article
RIBA Stirling Prize Winner 2022 – The New Library, Magdalene College

The Royal Institute of British Architects has named its winner of the 26th RIBA Stirling Prize, which is awarded to the best building in the UK. The Royal Institute of...

 Read Full Article
Inside One Canada Square's Latest Renovation

University College London School of Management has moved to the penthouse level of One Canada Square, Canary Wharf. The heavily oversubscribed University College...

 Read Full Article
SSE Trains University Facilities Managers on Net-Zero Implementation

To tackle the rising energy consumption of the majority of higher education institutions, SSE Energy Solutions is delivering decarbonisation training to FMs and Estates...

 Read Full Article
Julius Rutherfoord Retains £30m of London Cleaning Contracts

Julius Rutherfoord has retained £30 million worth of education cleaning contracts, including a contract extension at City, University of London. The retentions...

 Read Full Article