The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

EU Playing 'Key Part' for Cleaner Britain

20 April 2016 | Updated 01 January 1970

The Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) has joined the EU referendum debate with its latest report stating that the UK is better within than in the BREXIT fold.

In giving the Chair's comment at the start of the report, Mary Creagh MP was unequivocal when she stated on behalf of the EAC on the Environment: “EU environmental laws have played a key part and mean we bathe on cleaner beaches, drive more fuel-efficient cars and can hold government to account on air pollution."

The Committee heard that EU environmental policy development had been a ‘two-way street’. On the one hand, EU membership had given the UK a platform to pursue its environmental objectives internationally and influence the strategic, long term direction of policy. On the other, the Committee argued that EU membership had ‘ensured that environmental action in the UK has been taken on a faster timetable and more thoroughly than would otherwise have been the case’.


Less ability to influence

The inquiry heard concerns that a UK outside the EU would still have to follow some of its environmental legislation but with significantly less ability to influence how it would be developed. Not surprisingly, pro-EU government ministers told the Committee that a vote to leave would result in a ‘long and tortuous negotiation’ while business representatives felt a leave vote could remove long term certainty.  


Multilateral approach

The ‘overwhelming majority’ of witnesses said that there were benefits to solving some of our environmental problems multilaterally and that the UK’s membership of the EU has ensured that the UK environment had been better protected.

"Environmental problems don’t respect borders,” warned Creagh. “When it comes to protecting our natural environment and dealing with global problems like climate change, the overwhelming evidence is that EU membership has improved the UK’s approach to the environment and ensured that the UK’s environment has been better protected."

Witnesses told the Committee that membership of the EU had strengthened the UK’s approach to environmental protection. According to Angus Evers, Member and Co-convenor of the Waste Working Party at the UK Environmental Law Association (UKELA), the UK transitioned from the image of the Dirty Man of Europe  in the 1970s to “becoming one of the leaders of European environmental policy”.

In his submission, Professor Colin Reid, Professor of Environmental Law at the University of Dundee Law School, believed “EU involvement certainly ensured that action was taken on a faster timetable and more thoroughly than would otherwise have been the case”.

The Committee also cited witnesses who had given specific examples, including improvements in bathing water and air quality as well as waste disposal. One example was the Environmental Services Association (ESA) where it felt the Landfill Directive had led to a ‘huge reduction in UK methane emissions from landfill’.


The case for exit

In a damning indictment of the BREXIT group and one that will be certain to annoy its leaders, the Committee believed ‘relatively little appears to have been done by way of planning in the case of the UK leaving. None of the witnesses to our inquiry made an environmental case for leaving the EU.’

It felt there were ‘significant unanswered questions’ about what relationship a UK outside the EU would have with it and with the rest of the world, ‘just as there are unanswered questions as to how our relationship with the EU might develop’.

Picture:    The latest EAC report cited the view that the imposition of the Landfill Directive had led to a ‘huge reduction in UK methane emissions from landfill’

Article written by Mike Gannon | Published 20 April 2016


Related Articles

MAC Sharpens Knife to Cut to Heart of EU to UK Immigration

The Home Secretary Amber Rudd has (on July 27 - at least a year too late according to most observers) commissioned the Migration Advisory Committee to examine the role EU...

 Read Full Article
Runneth Your Cups Over to Costa

Costa is launching a nationwide recycling scheme across over 2,000 stores in order to recover and guarantee the recycling of its takeaway cups. Competitor takeaway cups...

 Read Full Article
Viridor Gives Interserve a Glasgow Kiss-off

International support services and construction group, Interserve, has been served notice of termination on its Glasgow Recycling & Renewable Energy project. The...

 Read Full Article
Paper? Seriously?

Many businesses are still overly reliant on paper – which is why AIIM’s World Paper Free Day looks to remind us of practical ways to de-clutter the...

 Read Full Article
Getting a First in Waste Emissions

Said to be the UK’s first waste report that calculates the carbon emissions generated during the waste management process, clients will now be given data for gross...

 Read Full Article
EU Emissions Agreed - On the Road to Unlock LC Billions or another Wasted Journey?

In the early hours of last Friday, EU Leaders agreed to further cuts in CO2 emissions - 40% by 2030, compared with 1990 levels - with the EC President Herman van Rompuyj...

 Read Full Article
Food Waste - Lords Call for Action

A House of Lords EU committee report has called for urgent action on food waste in Europe. It was published on Sunday (6 April) and among its recommendations was a clear...

 Read Full Article
All Waste is Resource Says Taylor

Michael Taylor (pictured), MD of Mitie’s waste business presented ‘Mitie’s waste revolution’ at last Thursday’s Building Futures Group...

 Read Full Article
New Rules for Lorries as Waste Contractor is Sued

All trucks will have to have the latest safety equipment in London as half of all cycle deaths are caused by lorries yet they only represent 4per cent of traffic....

 Read Full Article
The Resources And Waste Strategy Is Missing A Strategy

Defra's Resources And Waste Strategy For England was highly anticipated and yet can only be considered a wish list rather than a concrete plan according to Harvey...

 Read Full Article