The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Involuntary Work Hours Fuel Male Pay Inequality

19 January 2018 | Updated 01 January 1970

More men in lower paid roles are working fewer hours or part-time, while higher paid men are working more. These changes have led to a ‘hollowing out’ of the male labour force, with fewer middle earners, according to a new report published week ending January 19 by the Resolution Foundation.

The 'Counting the Hours' report finds that this hollowing out means that the share of low-paid men earning less than £175 a week (a third of the typical male weekly wage) has increased by 70 per cent over the last 20 years, while the share of higher-paid men earning more than £1,060 (double the typical weekly wage) has increased by 15 per cent.

In contrast, the share of middle-earning men – earning between £400 and £660 – has fallen by 15 per cent.

The report rejects the consensus view that ‘hollowing out’ (the growing polarisation of pay) is principally about the loss of mid-skilled jobs such as those in manufacturing. It notes that there has actually been relatively little occupational hollowing out in the UK overall, thanks to the rise of new professional and service sector mid-skilled jobs to replace the old ones.

The Foundation says that the explanation for the growing divide in weekly pay packets instead lies in the big shifts in men’s working patterns over the last 20 years, which have largely gone unnoticed. This hollowing out has been driven in part by the rising number of male part-time employees, which has increased by over 50 per cent since 1997. Almost one in eight men work part-time today, compared to fewer than one in twelve 20 years ago.

Counting the Hours also finds a growing divide in the number of hours that men working full-time do. The average number of hours worked by low-paid men had fallen from 44.3 hours in 1997 to 42.2 hours in 2016, while increasing by 0.5 hours to 37.3 hours for high-paid men.

Taking these two trends together, low-paid men now work fewer hours on average than higher-paid men (34.1 hours, compared to 36 hours) – a reversal of working patterns from 20 years ago.



There has been no such hollowing out for female workers, with the big change over the last 20 years being a small rise in the share of higher paid women, while both part-time and full-time women have increased their hours over the last 20 years.

The Foundation says that these changes are in part because of a more equal distribution of low-paid, part-time work between men and women. This is no bad thing, though the fact that over a quarter of low-paid men working part-time want a full-time job is a big concern. Involuntary part-time rates are highest for skilled tradespeople, cleaners, labourers, and those in sales and customer service jobs.

Furthermore, while levels of underemployment (those wanting more hours work than they currently get) are stable for higher paid workers, they are well-above the levels of the early 2000s for low-paid men. Policy makers must be alert to people drifting towards low-paid short-hours work against their will, says the Foundation.

Stephen Clarke, Policy Analyst at the Resolution Foundation, said: “When people talk about the labour market ‘hollowing out’ they’re normally referring to mid-skilled jobs moving to other parts of the world or disappearing altogether as a result of automation.

“But Britain’s real hollowing out problem has much more to do with the hours people are working than the rates of pay different jobs bring. The increase in earnings inequality among men is about the increasing number of low-paid men who are either reducing their hours or moving into part-time work, in some cases against their wishes.

“Stronger pay rises and finding work will always be the best and most direct way for households to boost their incomes. But being able to work the hours you want or need to get by also matter hugely.

“Women still dominate part time and low-paid work – but men are increasingly joining them. For the sake of both sexes we should be concerned about the numbers who find themselves there when they desperately need a full-time job.”

Picture: Involuntary part-time rates are highest for skilled tradespeople, cleaners, labourers, and those in sales and customer service jobs

Article written by Cathryn Ellis | Published 19 January 2018


Related Articles

Pay Cuts For Home Workers – Is it Fair?

As Google considers cutting pay for US workers who switch to permanent home working, is it fair to base salary on working location? A report by Reuters suggests that...

 Read Full Article
Mace and Amey to Tackle Gender Inequality in Construction

Two industry leaders from Mace and Amey have been appointed to spearhead a campaign to challenge gender inequality in the construction sector. Amanda Fisher,...

 Read Full Article
Gender Pay Gap in FM – Mandatory Reporting Delayed

Companies with more than 250 employees will not have to publish their gender pay gap until October 2021. The gender pay gap is the difference between the average (mean...

 Read Full Article
Mace Operate Launches Inclusive Business Strategy

Mace has today launched its 2026 business strategy, including reducing its gender and ethnicity pay gap by 10 per cent year on year. The new strategy sets out a...

 Read Full Article
Spruce Springclean Leads Band Of Great Trade Names

As we head in to the brighter future of 2020, ThisWeekinFM has teamed with a comparison site to identify some great trade names - and also discover a less than chirpy...

 Read Full Article
Gender Pay Gap Closes In Property & FM

The gender pay gap has closed in the real estate and built environment sector according to the latest RICS and Macdonald & Company Rewards and Attitudes Survey which...

 Read Full Article
Northern Exposure - Lack Of Commercial Property Could Stall Growth

Big Northern and Midlands cities are outperforming the rest of country in attracting jobs and residents to city centres – but action is needed to protect the...

 Read Full Article
Win For City, Dictating & Docs Go Green, Cloud Award & Ward Award

The full FM Digest features catering and doc management contract wins; employee motivation; and gender pay gap reporting PLUS seven stories more.   Manchester...

 Read Full Article
Call For Employers To Be Made Liable For Supply Chains Abuses

The TUC says that unless joint liability is extended to parent employers many supply chain workers will remain at risk of not receiving holiday pay and in the worst...

 Read Full Article
The Gender Pay Gap Grows Bigger With Age

Women earn £8,400 a year less than men by the time they hit 50 a study by the TUC has revealed as the congress also comments on sexual harassment at work. A new...

 Read Full Article