The Leading News & Information Service For The Facilities, Workplace & Built Environment Community

Safety Fines Reflect Size of Guilty Firms

11 May 2017 | Updated 01 January 1970

A construction company has been fined £3/4 million for asbestos failings; another for a falling load crush; another for a trench collapse; and another for an horrific chainsaw accident. The total fines and costs are over £one-and-a-half million - each fine reflects not just the seriousness of the cases but also the size of the firms involved.


Barroerock Construction Limited has been fined after repeated asbestos failings.

Canterbury Crown Court heard yesterday how the Health and Safety Executive carried out two investigations of working practices at a in Ashford, Kent site in 2013 and 2014 while Barroerock were converting a former nine storey office building, which was known to contain asbestos, in to flats.

The first investigation arose from a routine inspection during one of the HSE’s refurbishment campaigns. The Court was told that while a refurbishment and demolition survey had been carried out, the company had failed to act upon it. This resulted in up to 40 workers being exposed to asbestos during the early demolition phase of the project.

The second investigation culminated in a visit to the site in June 2014 following complaints being made about the health and safety practices at the site. It was found that despite engaging a licensed asbestos contractor to remove the remaining asbestos materials, dangerous practices were continuing. In addition the company was unable to provide documentation to show that asbestos materials identified in the survey had been correctly removed. When the work on site was halted for the second time, about 160 people were working inside the building.

It was found in both HSE investigations that these incidents could have been prevented if Barroerock ensured they had effective management controls in place to avoid the risk of exposure to asbestos.

Barroerock Construction pleaded guilty to two offences under the Construction Design and Management Regulations 2007 and was fined £750,000 and ordered to pay costs of £14,874.68.


DHL and JCB both fined after worker struck by overturning trolley and hydraulic rams

Stafford Crown Court heard how an employee of DHL Services Limited was auditing in-coming deliveries of equipment in an outside yard at JCB World Headquarters when he was struck from behind by falling machinery.  At the time of the incident the hydraulic rams were on a trolley being being towed by an electric tug.

The trolley toppled on its side trapping the DHL employee between it and a stillage. He suffered multiple serious injuries including fractures and internal injuries.

An HSE investigation into the incident which occurred on 16 October 2013 found there were a number of safety failures related to this auditing activity and the segregation between employees and vehicles using this area, leading to an unsafe system of work.

DHL pleaded guilty to breaching the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act and was fined £266,000 and ordered to pay costs of £23,370.22. JC Bamford Excavators pleaded guilty to breaching same Act and was fined £375,000 and ordered to pay costs of £37,235.42.

HSE Inspector David Brassington said after the hearing: “The dangers of failing to provide effective segregation between pedestrians and vehicles are well known. Both of these companies were well versed in transport risk management and both fell well below the required standard in ensuring that such risks were effectively managed in this area.”


Worker trapped in trench

A Fife construction company has been fined after a worker had to be dug out of a trench that collapsed onto him. Dundee Sheriff Court heard the 43-year-old employee of Wallace Roofing and Building Limited suffered a broken shoulder and collarbone as well as punctures to both of his lungs and fractures to all but two of his ribs.

Emergency services helped the rescue operation following the incident in September 2011. A trench was being dug. A man laying new piping in the trench. During this operation one of the trench walls, nine feet deep, subsided, burying the worker under the dislodged earth.

Workers immediately started digging the soil away from the man’s head to allow him to breathe. He remained partially buried in the trench until the emergency services arrived and dug him free. He remained in hospital for almost three weeks.

The HSE found that the trench had not been supported or ‘stepped back’, to control the risk of the trench collapsing. Inspectors also found that nobody had formal health and safety training for managing a construction site and that work involving the excavated trench had not been risk assessed. As a result, workers were given instructions through verbal briefings rather than detailed, mapped out planning.

Wallace Roofing and Building was fined £14,000.


Chainsaw incident

A company has been fined after an employee was seriously injured by a chainsaw while felling trees. Basildon Magistrates’ Court heard that an employee of Growing Green Limited suffered deep cuts to his arm while working with another colleague at the Brentwood Nursery on 6 April 2016.

The two employees were working together with one person holding and supporting the branches and the other cutting through them using the chainsaw. During this operation one man’s arm landed on top of the moving chainsaw. The man sustained deep lacerations damaging the nerves in his arm.

The HSE found that neither man had been trained to operate the chainsaw, nor were the pair wearing any personal protective equipment (i.e. chainsaw trousers and jacket, chainsaw gloves, safety helmet, safety boots and eye protection). There was no supervision and no proper planning had been put in place.

Growing Green was fined £120,000, including a £170 victim surcharge, and ordered to pay costs of £1,864.35.

Speaking after the case, HSE Inspector Tania van Rixtel said: “It was only luck that the gentleman did not lose his arm."

Picture: A chainsaw for illustration purposes only

Article written by Brian Shillibeer | Published 11 May 2017


Related Articles

Dursley Does It - Fine For School Unlicensed Asbestos Removal

A company has been fined following an unlicensed asbestos removal from a school. The unsafe and unlicensed removal occurred during refurbishment works at Dursley...

 Read Full Article
Shocking Ways to Land in Court

BAM Construction Limited and Shoreland Projects Limited have been fined after a man suffered multiple life changing injuries including severe burns to his...

 Read Full Article
Asbestos Analyst Fined for Falsifying Documents

An asbestos analyst has been fined after he falsified an asbestos air clearance certificate, following licensed asbestos removal in Manchester. Greater Manchester...

 Read Full Article
Cavalier Estate Management Firm Fined Again

A real estate company in Oxfordshire has been fined for failing to manage asbestos on its premises following a fire. Reading Crown Court heard how a fire occurred at...

 Read Full Article
Fathers' Day - Killings Get Scant Justice

A company providing environmental services has been prosecuted after a worker was killed during asbestos removal work at a Welsh High school. Newport Magistrates Court...

 Read Full Article
Phoenix Nights Delayed by Asbestos Exposure

A Bolton night club owner has been sentenced after admitting a failure to carry out a survey for asbestos before starting on the refurbishment of a local night...

 Read Full Article
GM Drives into Asbestos Trouble

General Motors UK Ltd has been prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive after work being undertaken at its North Road, Ellesmere Port site in 2014 exposed...

 Read Full Article
Airline Company Guilty For Unsafe Operation of Passenger Lift

Flybe, the airline company, was sentenced on 4 February 2020 for the unsafe operation of a passenger lift. Meanwhile, a number of other firms have found themselves...

 Read Full Article
Newnham College Cambridge Lands Asbestos Failings Fine

Newnham College Cambridge has been fined for failings that exposed employees and subcontractors to asbestos during refurbishment of a flat owned by the...

 Read Full Article
Hotel All At Sea Over Asbestos

Two companies have been fined. RJW Building Solutions, a contractor carrying out refurbishment work at the Sea Hotel in South Shields and Hotel 52, the client, were...

 Read Full Article